What’s Happening in the Negotiation Room? Lindor Reveals Conversations Between Mets and Pete Alonso

As the New York Mets continue navigating their rollercoaster 2025 MLB campaign, one major storyline has emerged from behind the scenes: Pete Alonso’s contract situation. While Alonso’s bat continues to do the talking on the field, it’s his contractual future that’s stirring conversation off of it—particularly thanks to recent comments made by Francisco Lindor.

Lindor, a cornerstone of the Mets’ long-term vision, offered an intriguing insight into what the future might hold for his power-hitting teammate. During his appearance on The Show: A NY Post Baseball Podcast with Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman on June 17, the star shortstop suggested that Pete Alonso may actually pursue an extension with the Mets—before testing free agency.

In a world where most assume Alonso is bound to hit the open market, Lindor’s prediction has reignited speculation about how committed Alonso is to staying in Queens long term.

The Power Trio: Lindor, Soto, and Alonso

The New York Mets boast one of the most potent offensive trios in baseball: Francisco Lindor, Juan Soto, and Pete Alonso. Two-thirds of that trio are already locked down with mega-deals. Lindor signed his massive 10-year, $341 million extension back in 2021, while Juan Soto committed to a staggering 15-year, $765 million contract this past offseason, signaling New York’s full buy-in to build around its star hitters.

But Pete Alonso, the 2022 Home Run Derby Champion and a franchise icon since debuting in 2019, has not yet received the same long-term commitment.

Alonso agreed to a two-year, $54 million deal in February that included a player opt-out after the 2025 season. The prevailing assumption has been that he’ll exercise the opt-out clause and test free agency—especially given how stellar his 2025 campaign has been so far.

But according to Francisco Lindor, that may not be the case.

Lindor’s Surprising Take on Pete Alonso’s Contract Intentions

Speaking candidly about Alonso on The Show podcast, Lindor said:

“He means a lot to us. I was happy he came back. He makes our team better, he lengthens our lineup. The way he’s playing this year is incredible. Super happy for him.”

Then came the curveball.

“I don’t know what he’s going to end up doing this year, but I’m sure he’s gonna try for an extension, and make the most money he can.”

That remark suggests something many had not seriously considered: that Alonso might want to stay in New York long-term and will attempt to negotiate with the Mets before testing the market.

Lindor even praised how Alonso handled past negotiations:

“Credit to him. He went out there… he came back with a good contract,” Lindor said. “And throughout the negotiations, it’s one of those where the team gave what they felt was the best offer they could give. And Pete, in all his rights, wanted to make sure he made the best decision for him and his family.”

Why an Extension Might Make Sense for Alonso

So, why would Pete Alonso consider a contract extension before opting out in 2025?

Several factors might play into that decision:

• Stability: The Mets are clearly building a long-term contender. With Lindor and Soto locked in, Alonso would solidify a “Big Three” for years to come.

• Familiarity: Alonso is beloved in New York, from the fanbase to the clubhouse. Leaving that behind isn’t easy.

• Market Uncertainty: While Alonso is a top-tier slugger, the first base market in free agency has historically been inconsistent. There’s no guarantee he’d receive a significantly better offer than what the Mets might put on the table.

• Legacy: Alonso has a chance to be remembered as one of the greatest Mets of all time. Staying in Queens would help cement that status.

And with Francisco Lindor now publicly floating the idea of an extension, it could be a subtle nudge to both Alonso and the front office.

Alonso’s 2025 Season So Far: MVP-Caliber

The conversation about Alonso’s future wouldn’t even be happening if he weren’t playing elite baseball—but he is. Through mid-June, Pete Alonso has smashed 20+ home runs, driven in over 60 RBIs, and is hitting close to .290.

He’s also shown improved plate discipline and remains one of the most feared power hitters in the league. His bat has been critical in several clutch moments this season, helping the Mets stay afloat in a tightly contested NL East race.

If he keeps producing at this pace, Alonso could be in line for an MVP nomination—and possibly a record-breaking payday.

What Would a New Contract Look Like?

If the Mets do decide to pursue an extension, what might it cost?

Alonso will be 30 by the time he opts out, making this his best opportunity to cash in on a long-term deal. Here are some potential numbers:

• Years: 7 to 9

• Total Value: $180 to $240 million

• AAV (Average Annual Value): Around $27M–$30M

Comparatively, Paul Goldschmidt signed a 5-year, $130 million deal in 2019 with the Cardinals, and Freddie Freeman’s contract with the Dodgers totals $162 million over six years. Given the inflation in player salaries and Alonso’s power pedigree, a contract north of $200 million wouldn’t be surprising.

The only question is whether Steve Cohen’s front office—already shelling out big bucks for Lindor and Soto—is ready to open the vault for a third cornerstone bat.

Could Another Team Lure Alonso Away?

Of course, if Alonso does not sign an extension, the list of suitors in free agency could be long.

Teams like the Chicago Cubs, San Francisco Giants, or even the Boston Red Sox might be in the market for a power-hitting first baseman. And with Alonso’s leadership skills, clubhouse presence, and elite bat, he’ll command attention from contenders.

But again, if Alonso truly wants to stay—as Lindor suggests—he may try to strike a deal before that bidding war even begins.

The Mets’ Perspective: Do They Want Alonso Long-Term?

From a team-building standpoint, keeping Pete Alonso would check several boxes for the Mets:

• Consistency at the plate

• Fan favorite who boosts ticket sales and merchandise

• Proven playoff performer with a track record of stepping up in big games

The only hesitation could come from positional depth. First base is typically easier to replace than, say, shortstop or center field. But Alonso’s unique power makes him irreplaceable for a team trying to win now.

If the Mets are serious about competing into the late 2020s, keeping their core intact is essential.

Francisco Lindor’s Comments Add Pressure to Front Office

Lindor isn’t just a teammate—he’s a team leader, and his public support for Alonso sends a message to Mets management: “Let’s get this done.”

By making his belief known that Alonso will pursue an extension, Lindor has effectively placed the spotlight on the front office. Will they respond? Will they initiate talks before Alonso’s opt-out?

This could be a turning point in Alonso’s contract saga.

Conclusion: Is Pete Alonso the Next Met to Get Paid?

The New York Mets have already made massive investments in Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto, and it’s clear they view the two as centerpieces of their championship vision.

But if Pete Alonso truly wants to stay, and if Lindor’s prediction proves accurate, we may see the Mets’ most iconic slugger ink a long-term deal before the 2025 season ends.

For fans, that would be a dream scenario—ensuring that the Lindor-Soto-Alonso trio remains a force in New York for years to come.

And for Alonso? It could be the chance to continue building his legacy in the only uniform he’s ever known.

Stay tuned, Mets fans. This story is just heating up.