Pete Alonso Responds to Juan Soto: ‘765 Million Dollars? I Will Prove My True Value!

In the world of Major League Baseball, few rivalries stir as much buzz as that between sluggers Pete Alonso and Juan Soto. But after Soto’s record-breaking $765 million extension with the New York Yankees made headlines, the tension reached new heights. In a fiery response that lit up social media and sports talk shows alike, Pete Alonso vowed to prove his worth on and off the field.

“765 million dollars? Great for him. But I’ll prove my true value with the bat, not the bank.”

As the baseball world debates whether anyone else deserves a contract in Soto’s stratosphere, Alonso’s comments signal a new chapter in what’s becoming one of the most compelling slugger rivalries in the game today.

Juan Soto’s Mega Deal Shakes MLB

Earlier this year, Juan Soto shocked fans by signing a 15-year, $765 million deal with the New York Yankees, making it the richest contract in the history of professional sports. Soto, a perennial MVP candidate and offensive machine, quickly became the face of the Yankees’ future alongside Aaron Judge.

The contract sent ripples through MLB. Players, agents, and analysts began questioning who might be next in line for a mega-payday. That’s when Pete Alonso’s name began circulating.

The New York Mets’ powerhouse first baseman has consistently ranked among the top home run hitters since his debut. With his free agency looming, many wondered if the Mets would shell out a comparable deal. Alonso’s response to the Soto news, however, wasn’t about money—it was about pride.

“I’m not chasing someone else’s check. I’m chasing legacy. You can’t put a price on that.”

Alonso vs. Soto: The Slugger Rivalry Heats Up

While Juan Soto is known for his plate discipline and ability to hit to all fields, Pete Alonso represents old-school power hitting. Since entering the league in 2019, Alonso has led MLB in home runs, including a record-setting 53-homer rookie season.

Their contrasting styles make for a thrilling comparison:

Despite Soto’s contract making headlines, Alonso’s consistency and leadership in Queens cannot be overlooked.

“Soto’s got a great bat, no doubt. But I’ll go toe-to-toe with anyone when the lights are brightest,” Alonso told The Athletic.

Contract Pressure and Free Agency Looming

Alonso, 29, is entering a pivotal stage of his career. With free agency on the horizon after the 2025 season, his performance this year will play a massive role in determining his market value. While the Mets have yet to offer an extension publicly, fans and insiders believe it’s only a matter of time before negotiations heat up.

Insiders say that Alonso could command upwards of $300 million, especially if he maintains his power-hitting pace and improves his on-base numbers.

“If Pete hits 45 homers and drives in 120 RBIs again, the Mets will have to back up the Brinks truck,” one NL executive said anonymously.

Mets Front Office: A Calculated Gamble

Under new president of baseball operations David Stearns, the Mets are being more strategic about contracts. After unloading several high-priced veterans in 2023, including Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander, the team is rebuilding with a focus on analytics, depth, and youth.

Alonso, however, represents more than just numbers—he’s the emotional core of the team.

“We love Pete. He embodies everything we want in a Met,” manager Carlos Mendoza recently said. “But we also have to make the right long-term decisions for the club.”

That statement has led some to speculate whether the Mets are hesitant to match the long-term deals being offered around the league, including Soto’s.

Alonso’s Message to Mets Ownership: I’m Worth It

In multiple interviews since Soto’s deal, Alonso has kept the focus on performance, not money. But make no mistake—his message is calculated.

“I’ll earn every dollar I make. Let’s see where we all stand after October.”

That’s a direct challenge not only to Juan Soto, but also to Mets ownership, who must now decide whether to lock down their franchise slugger or risk losing him to a team like the Chicago Cubs, San Francisco Giants, or even the New York Yankees—who could pair him with Soto in a nightmare scenario for Mets fans.

Fan Reactions: Mets Nation Rallies Behind Alonso

Fans across social media have been overwhelmingly supportive of Alonso’s response:

• @MetsDieHard22: “Soto’s great but Alonso is the Mets. He’s earned every penny. PAY HIM NOW.”

• @BaseballLifer: “Love the fire from Pete. Soto got his bag. Now it’s Alonso’s turn to show why he’s the king of NY.”

A fan-made sign at Citi Field during a recent Mets home game read:

“$765 million? Give Alonso the crown instead!“

The message is clear: Mets fans see Alonso as their cornerstone, and many are hoping the front office feels the same.

Alonso’s Legacy and New York Pressure

There’s more at stake than just a contract. Alonso wants to be remembered as one of the greatest Mets of all time—a goal that drives every swing he takes.

If he continues to produce, he’ll join the likes of David Wright, Mike Piazza, and Tom Seaver as franchise legends. But the road to that legacy runs through October—and potentially through Soto’s Yankees.

“I love New York. I love the Mets. I want to win a ring here. That’s all that matters to me,” Alonso said.

Still, if the Mets hesitate, Alonso could follow the money elsewhere, much like Jacob deGrom did when he signed with the Texas Rangers.

Could Alonso and Soto Battle in October?

With the Yankees and Mets both pushing for postseason runs, an Alonso vs. Soto showdown in the World Series isn’t out of the question. The hype would be enormous:

• Two New York sluggers

• Massive contracts

• Crosstown bragging rights

• Legacy on the line

Such a matchup would bring back memories of the 2000 Subway Series—and perhaps write a new chapter in New York baseball history.

Final Thoughts: Alonso Aims to Let His Bat Do the Talking

As Juan Soto basks in his historic contract, Pete Alonso is sharpening his bat and letting the baseball world know he’s ready for his moment.

He may not have the $765 million contract (yet), but if his bat keeps booming, his true value will be undeniable.

Whether it’s in Queens or somewhere else, Pete Alonso is set to make the MLB’s financial landscape even more competitive. And if you ask him, he wouldn’t want it any other way.

“I’m not chasing money. I’m chasing greatness. And greatness will get you paid.”