Joseph Parker Praised as the Best but Hasn’t Defeated Usyk, AJ, or Fury: Does He Truly Deserve a Title Shot?

In the dynamic world of heavyweight boxing, few names have sparked as much debate in recent months as Joseph Parker. Once a WBO world champion and now on an impressive resurgence, Parker has earned praise from fans and analysts alike. Some even argue he’s among the most technically refined and improved heavyweights in the division today. But despite the accolades, a critical question remains: Can Joseph Parker truly be considered deserving of another title shot when he has not beaten Oleksandr Usyk, Anthony Joshua, or Tyson Fury?

The three titans—Usyk, AJ, and Fury—are widely regarded as the elite of the division. Each has either held or currently holds heavyweight gold and boasts defining victories. Parker, while skilled and likable, has faced two of them (AJ and Fury) and come up short. As boxing angles toward unification bouts and legacy-defining matchups, Parker’s claim to a world title opportunity warrants a closer examination.

Joseph Parker’s Career Resurgence: A Different Fighter Now

One of the most compelling arguments for Parker’s case is the undeniable transformation in his fighting style and mentality over the last few years. Since his 2018 losses to Anthony Joshua (via unanimous decision) and Dillian Whyte, Parker has looked like a man reborn in the ring. Under the guidance of trainer Andy Lee and with support from close friend Tyson Fury, Parker has refined his footwork, tightened his combinations, and drastically improved his defensive composure and ring generalship.

His recent win over Zhilei Zhang in March 2024 caught the attention of the entire division. Zhang, fresh off two knockout wins over Joe Joyce, was expected to be a brutal test. Instead, Parker showcased elite timing, slick movement, and a well-executed game plan that earned him a majority decision victory and elevated his standing as a top-5 heavyweight again.

Yet, despite this impressive form, questions persist. Zhang is not a reigning champion. And while Parker has racked up quality wins recently, none have come against the current title-holders or those who have held belts in the past three years.

The Missing Wins: Usyk, AJ, and Fury

Perhaps the most glaring issue with Parker’s resume is the absence of wins against the “Big Three”: Oleksandr Usyk, Anthony Joshua, and Tyson Fury. These men represent the gold standard in heavyweight boxing today, and each possesses a unique challenge that Parker has either not solved or not even attempted yet.

Against Anthony Joshua, Parker fought a measured, if slightly passive, fight in 2018. That bout saw Parker go the full 12 rounds, becoming the first fighter to take AJ the distance up to that point. While commendable, the performance lacked urgency and aggression, and Joshua comfortably outpointed him.

Tyson Fury, meanwhile, faced Parker in a non-title bout at the end of 2023. Parker was durable and active, but again, Fury’s size, reach, and awkward rhythm proved too much. Though Parker showed grit, the result was decisive: Fury won on points.

Oleksandr Usyk remains the only one of the trio Parker hasn’t fought. Usyk’s brilliant movement and unorthodox angles would present a nightmare for Parker, who often performs best against slower, more stationary opponents.

Without wins over any of these champions, it becomes hard to place Parker at the top of the queue for a title shot—especially when fighters like Filip Hrgović, Jared Anderson, or even Deontay Wilder could also make strong claims depending on how future fights unfold.

Is Praise Enough Without Proof?

It’s not uncommon in boxing for a fighter to be praised based on perceived improvement and potential rather than past accomplishments. Parker is certainly benefiting from this trend, especially as analysts note his increased sharpness and renewed focus since training with Tyson Fury’s camp. However, praise must eventually be validated in the ring—and not just against fringe contenders.

Yes, Parker beat Junior Fa, Dereck Chisora (twice), Jack Massey, and Zhilei Zhang, but none of these names are part of the undisputed puzzle. Praise alone cannot push a fighter into title contention—proof, in the form of elite-level victories, must be the standard.

The boxing world has a long memory, and while past losses can be forgiven, they are rarely forgotten. If Parker wants to earn a title shot the right way, a statement win over a current or recent champion is the clearest path.

The Case For Parker: Experience, Momentum, and Marketability

Still, the argument for Joseph Parker receiving a title shot isn’t without merit. For one, Parker is a former world champion. He knows what it takes to prepare for a title fight and won’t wilt under the spotlight. His experience against top-tier fighters, even in losses, gives him an edge in composure that many rising stars lack.

Secondly, Parker is on a legitimate win streak. Momentum matters in boxing, and with his name frequently discussed on commentary panels and boxing shows, he’s becoming hard to ignore. He has made himself relevant through wins and style—not trash talk or manufactured drama.

And finally, Parker is marketable. He’s respected globally, especially in New Zealand and the UK, and has a wholesome image that appeals to a broad demographic. A Parker title fight could generate solid pay-per-view numbers and international interest, especially if hosted in the Southern Hemisphere, where major boxing events are relatively rare.

How Does He Earn It Now?

If Joseph Parker is serious about pushing for a world title shot in 2025, he must target one of two things:

1. A victory over an elite heavyweight contender like Filip Hrgović, Jared Anderson, or Frank Sanchez. These names are rising fast and bring legitimacy. Beating one would solidify Parker’s spot as next in line.

2. A rematch with Anthony Joshua or even Deontay Wilder, should either fight be available. If Parker can avenge a past loss or derail a power puncher like Wilder, his title shot argument becomes irrefutable.

Short of that, lobbying for a direct shot without those scalps will continue to draw criticism, regardless of how polished his current form may be.

What the Fans and Critics Are Saying

Fans online remain divided. Some believe Parker’s consistency, demeanor, and recent performances make him a worthy challenger, especially in contrast to more erratic fighters like Wilder or Andy Ruiz Jr.

Others are not convinced. One comment on a Reddit boxing thread summed up the sentiment: “Parker’s a good guy and a better fighter now than ever—but if you haven’t beaten any of the current or recent champs, how can you call yourself the next best?”

Critics in the media also echo this viewpoint. ESPN’s boxing analyst Tim Bradley recently said, “Parker looks excellent—but the resume needs that signature win. Zhang is a good one, but it’s not enough.”

Final Verdict: Close, But Not Quite Yet

In boxing, momentum is critical—but it must be backed by meaningful victories. Joseph Parker is undeniably one of the most improved heavyweights in the division, and his recent performances have re-established him as a top contender. His work ethic, humility, and technical progress deserve genuine praise.

However, until he defeats one of the top three—Usyk, Fury, or Joshua—or at least dominates another elite contender, the idea of him jumping straight into a title shot remains tenuous. He’s close, perhaps even next in line after the smoke clears from the heavyweight unification bouts. But for now, Parker is still one defining win away from truly demanding another shot at glory.

What’s Next for Parker?

If he wants to silence all doubt, Parker’s team should aggressively pursue the biggest fight available—be it Hrgović, Wilder, or a Joshua rematch. Even a tough test against someone like Frank Sanchez could offer credibility. Parker’s story isn’t over; in fact, his second chapter may just be getting started.

But if he wants to be champion again, he must do what all great champions do: beat the best. And right now, the best still haven’t been added to his win column.