Are the Red Sox quietly pursuing Pete Alonso? What does the Mets’ internal team say about the risk of losing the ‘Polar Bear’?

It started as a whisper in the backrooms of the MLB winter meetings. Now it’s becoming louder with each passing game: Are the Boston Red Sox preparing a secret bid for New York Mets slugger Pete Alonso? Though nothing has been confirmed by either team, sources close to league insiders claim that the Red Sox front office is keeping a close watch on Alonso’s situation, evaluating whether a blockbuster move could shake up both franchises’ futures.

The Red Sox, hungry to reinvigorate their offense and fan base, have long admired Pete Alonso’s combination of power, leadership, and consistency. With Boston lacking a definitive power bat in the middle of their lineup, the idea of adding a proven slugger like Alonso is being discussed internally—even if it’s behind closed doors.

Pete Alonso: The Mets’ Identity and Dilemma

Since his MLB debut in 2019, Pete Alonso has been the face of the Mets’ offense. Nicknamed the “Polar Bear” for both his power and presence, Alonso set the rookie home run record with 53 bombs and hasn’t looked back. He’s been the rock amid the franchise’s many fluctuations, racking up multiple 40+ homer seasons, All-Star appearances, and fan admiration.

Yet as the 2025 season unfolds, contract uncertainty is casting a long shadow. Alonso is slated to become a free agent after this season, and negotiations have reportedly stalled. According to team sources, the Mets front office is divided. One faction believes Alonso is a franchise cornerstone who must be retained at any cost, while another group worries that a massive long-term deal could backfire, especially given the team’s recent spending history and mediocre returns.

With Steve Cohen’s payroll already under scrutiny, the Mets are balancing Alonso’s emotional and on-field value against the hard business of roster construction and financial flexibility.

The Red Sox’s Angle: Calculated Aggression

The Boston Red Sox are no strangers to bold moves. While recent years have seen the club operate more cautiously under Chaim Bloom, the new front-office direction post-Bloom is signaling a potential return to aggressive talent acquisition. With a roster that’s hovering around .500 and lacking an intimidating middle-of-the-order threat, Boston executives are said to be intrigued by Alonso’s unique ability to change games with one swing.

While Rafael Devers remains the team’s offensive anchor, the lineup around him has lacked depth and fear factor. Adding Alonso—who could theoretically slot into first base or DH—would not only lengthen the batting order but send a message to the fan base that Boston is ready to win now.

The timing makes sense. If Alonso becomes available at the trade deadline, or even in a winter free agency scenario, Boston is one of the few teams with both the payroll flexibility and prospect capital to make a real offer.

Would the Mets Actually Let Alonso Walk?

On the surface, letting Pete Alonso walk away would be a public relations nightmare for the Mets. Fans adore him. He’s never stirred controversy. He hits home runs, drives in runs, and plays hard. He’s everything New York claims to love.

Yet there are warning signs. Despite Alonso’s value, the Mets are under new operational philosophies—emphasizing analytics, youth development, and payroll efficiency. Alonso, who is projected to command a deal well north of $200 million, doesn’t fit the mold of a long-term asset under this model. His defensive limitations, age (30 next season), and one-dimensional profile have reportedly raised concerns among some Mets decision-makers.

One team official, speaking anonymously, said:

“We love Pete. He’s a great Met. But we also have to ask tough questions. Is he worth $30 million a year through his mid-30s? Is that the best way to build a championship team?“

The sentiment reveals the complexity of Alonso’s situation. It’s not just about what he’s done—it’s about what he will do, and whether that production justifies what could be a record-setting deal for a first baseman.

Alonso’s Camp Stays Silent—But Prepared

Interestingly, Alonso and his agents have maintained a strategic silence about contract talks. There’s been no public posturing, no demands, no ultimatums. But make no mistake—his team knows his value.

Behind the scenes, Alonso is reportedly open to staying in New York, but only if he feels respected in negotiations and if the team demonstrates a clear plan for contention. The Mets’ chaotic inconsistency over the past three years has frustrated not just fans, but players like Alonso who want to win now.

If Alonso feels that Boston offers a clearer vision—or more money—he might not hesitate to jump ship.

Could a Trade Happen Before Free Agency?

A trade involving Pete Alonso before the deadline would be seismic, but not impossible. The Mets, currently outside of the playoff picture, must decide whether to let Alonso walk for nothing or explore deadline trade possibilities to recoup value.

This is where Boston’s quiet pursuit becomes critical. If the Red Sox feel they can convince Alonso to sign long-term, they could make a bold move and offer top-tier prospects to rent him for the stretch run.

Names like Marcelo Mayer, Kyle Teel, or Nick Yorke would likely be required to even open talks. But Boston’s front office reportedly believes Alonso’s presence could revitalize Fenway, electrify fans, and give them a puncher’s chance in the crowded AL East.

It would be a bold, expensive gamble—but one that could change both teams’ trajectories.

The Fan Reactions: Love, Loyalty, and Panic

Among Mets fans, the idea of losing Pete Alonso is met with a mix of outrage and resignation. Social media has been flooded with emotional posts demanding a new deal, accusing ownership of cheapness, and even threatening boycotts.

But others are beginning to accept a painful truth: baseball is business, and Alonso’s future in Queens is no guarantee.

Red Sox fans, meanwhile, are cautiously excited. The idea of pairing Alonso with Devers in a power-loaded lineup is appealing. For a franchise that’s been adrift since 2021, landing Alonso would be a statement of renewed intent.

What Comes Next: A Decision with Consequences

With the trade deadline approaching and the offseason looming, both the Mets and Alonso are staring at a crossroads. The Red Sox may be circling. Other teams—like the Cubs, Giants, and Mariners—are also rumored to be monitoring the situation. But Boston has the combination of urgency, resources, and fit to be the most dangerous suitor.

If the Mets sign Alonso, they secure an icon and avoid a PR nightmare. But they also tie themselves to a potentially expensive, declining asset.

If they let him go—or trade him—they’ll face backlash, but perhaps gain flexibility to build around a younger, more modern core.

For Alonso, the decision will be about money, loyalty, and legacy. Will he become a lifetime Met? Or will he take his legendary power to a city like Boston, where the Green Monster awaits his towering blasts?