Shawn Mendes’ “Treat You Better” Just Hit 9 Years—But Everyone Is Shocked by What’s Been Hidden

It’s been nine years since Shawn Mendes dropped one of the most defining tracks of his early career: “Treat You Better.” A song that catapulted him from a social media sensation to a bona fide pop superstar, this track resonated deeply with millions worldwide. But as this anniversary quietly passed, a fresh wave of discussion has erupted online — not just about the song’s catchy melody or Mendes’ impressive vocals, but about the hidden layers and controversial undertones many missed the first time around.

While the world has moved on to Shawn’s newer hits and evolving musical style, “Treat You Better” remains a pop culture touchstone—its lyrics are still dissected, its message is debated, and its place in Mendes’ career is critically examined. What exactly is lurking beneath this seemingly straightforward track? And why is it suddenly sparking such a heated conversation nearly a decade later?

The Origins of a Breakout Hit

Back in 2016, Shawn Mendes was riding the wave of early fame built on YouTube covers and social media hype. His debut album, “Handwritten,” introduced the world to his raw talent and earnest songwriting. Then came “Treat You Better,” the lead single from his second album, “Illuminate.” The track’s infectious guitar riff and relatable lyrics quickly earned it a spot atop the charts, while music videos and live performances amplified its popularity.

The song’s central theme—a young man pleading for a girl to leave her current boyfriend for him because he can “treat you better”—struck a chord with listeners craving authenticity and emotional honesty in pop music. But, as with many pop songs that ride the wave of popularity, the simplicity of its message belied a more complicated cultural reception.

What Critics and Listeners Missed

The controversy surrounding “Treat You Better” largely centers on its lyrical narrative and the power dynamics it subtly implies. The protagonist insists that the girl is “in a bad relationship” and that he, unlike her current boyfriend, can truly care for her. This framing triggered a divided response from critics and audiences alike.

Some praised the song for its emotional intensity and heartfelt delivery, viewing it as a sincere appeal against unhealthy relationships. Others, however, argued that the lyrics toe a fine line, veering into controlling or possessive territory—an aspect that has only gained sharper scrutiny in today’s more aware cultural climate.

The phrase “I know I can treat you better” has been dissected as potentially patronizing, suggesting the woman lacks awareness or agency and raising questions about the message’s alignment with healthy relationship dynamics. In fact, many vocal online commentators in 2025 have revisited the track, pointing out how what was once a seemingly innocent pop anthem can now read as problematic.

The Social Media Reawakening

Recently, TikTok and Twitter users have resurrected the song with viral clips and heated debates, prompting a new generation to revisit Shawn Mendes’ early work through a critical lens. Hashtags related to the song and its anniversary have trended intermittently, fueling conversations about not just the track but broader discussions about pop music’s role in shaping ideas about love and respect.

Interestingly, this resurgence isn’t driven by Mendes himself, who has largely stayed silent on the track’s renewed scrutiny. Instead, it’s grassroots online discussion—spanning from casual listeners to music critics—that’s redefining the song’s legacy.

Shawn Mendes: Growth and Artistic Evolution

Since “Treat You Better,” Shawn Mendes has matured as an artist, both in sound and subject matter. His more recent albums reveal a willingness to tackle complex emotions with nuance and vulnerability. Tracks like “In My Blood” and “Wonder” showcase a deepened introspection and a softer touch in storytelling, arguably addressing some of the critiques leveled against his earlier work.

This artistic growth contrasts starkly with the blunt earnestness of “Treat You Better,” which now seems emblematic of a youthful naiveté that Mendes has consciously evolved beyond. Yet, this song’s enduring popularity ensures it remains an essential part of his narrative, even if it’s one that invites controversy.

The Public Perception Shift

The online uproar around the track highlights the evolving expectations audiences have for artists today. While “Treat You Better” once symbolized a romantic promise, it now serves as a cultural text revealing the changing landscape of how relationships and gender dynamics are viewed.

It’s worth noting that the demographics engaging with the song’s legacy are diverse, ranging from longtime admirers to critical outsiders who see it as a reflection of broader issues within pop music’s portrayal of romance.

Why the Song Still Resonates—And Provokes

At its core, “Treat You Better” embodies the tension between romantic idealism and modern skepticism. It’s catchy, relatable, and emotionally charged—but it also carries undertones that today’s audiences are less willing to overlook.

This duality makes it perfect fodder for discussions about the evolution of pop culture, the role of music in shaping social attitudes, and the often blurry line between sincere emotion and problematic messaging.

The Road Ahead: Shawn Mendes and His Legacy

As Shawn Mendes continues to shape his career, this anniversary invites reflection not only on the song itself but on the artist’s trajectory. How does one reconcile early work with evolving values? How should artists respond to retrospective critiques of their past material? And what does this mean for the broader conversation about music’s role in society?

These questions underscore the complex relationship between celebrity, culture, and audience in the digital age—where every song, statement, or performance can be endlessly analyzed, debated, and reinterpreted.

Final Thoughts

“Treat You Better” remains a defining moment in Shawn Mendes’ career—a song that launched him into stardom and continues to spark conversations years later. Whether celebrated for its heartfelt message or critiqued for its implications, the track stands as a vivid reminder of how pop music both reflects and influences cultural values.

In the end, this anniversary isn’t just about nostalgia—it’s about reckoning with the past and recognizing the power of music to provoke thought, challenge assumptions, and evolve with its audience.