Pete Alonso reveals the reason he didn’t sign with the Blue Jays despite a better offer

Pete Alonso, the power-hitting first baseman for the New York Mets, has officially re-signed with the franchise on a two-year, $54 million deal, allowing him the option to enter free agency after the 2025 season. This decision came after Alonso rejected a more lucrative three-year, $70 million contract from the Mets, reportedly due to its deferred payment structure. Additionally, the Toronto Blue Jays emerged as a strong contender in the race for Alonso’s signature, with reports indicating that they were prepared to offer a four-year, $116 million contract in a bid to lure him away from New York. However, on April 2, 2025, a post on X from @bluejaysaggr cited Yardbarker, revealing Alonso’s reasoning behind his decision to stay in Queens.

Pete Alonso’s Loyalty to the Mets

Despite the financial appeal of the Blue Jays’ offer, Pete Alonso chose to remain with the Mets due to his deep-rooted connection with the organization and its fanbase. Since making his MLB debut in 2019, Alonso has become a cornerstone of the Mets’ lineup, earning the affectionate nickname “Polar Bear” from fans who admire his powerful home runs and passionate playstyle. Alonso views Citi Field as his true home and expressed a desire to continue building his legacy in New York rather than seeking a fresh start elsewhere.

Alonso’s decision was driven not solely by financial incentives but also by sentimental and competitive factors. The Mets have provided him with a platform to thrive as one of the league’s top sluggers, and he has reciprocated with historic performances, including his 226 home runs since 2019—trailing only Aaron Judge in that timeframe.

Contract Negotiations and the Blue Jays’ Aggressive Pursuit

As Alonso entered free agency, the Mets initially attempted to secure a long-term commitment with a three-year, $70 million offer, which included deferred payments. However, Alonso and his agent, Scott Boras, declined the proposal in favor of a shorter-term deal that would provide greater financial flexibility. The Blue Jays, recognizing Alonso’s immense value, aggressively pursued him, reportedly engaging in “progressing discussions” as late as January 2025. Some sources indicated that the Blue Jays’ front office was prepared to make Alonso a centerpiece of their offense alongside Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

However, despite the financial allure, Alonso ultimately declined the offer. Reports suggest that a key sticking point was the potential deferral of salary payments, something Alonso and Boras were unwilling to accept. Additionally, Alonso reportedly had reservations about leaving New York for a smaller market like Toronto, preferring to remain in the national spotlight provided by the Mets.

Competitive Aspirations and Mets’ Future Outlook

Beyond financial considerations, Alonso’s decision to stay was influenced by the Mets’ long-term vision and their ability to compete for a World Series title. The franchise made a resounding statement by signing superstar outfielder Juan Soto to a record-breaking 15-year, $765 million contract, signaling a commitment to sustained excellence. Alonso likely saw this move as a testament to the Mets’ ambition, reassuring him that he would be part of a competitive squad capable of contending for championships.

Had Alonso signed with the Blue Jays, he would have undoubtedly bolstered their offensive prowess, but questions remained about Toronto’s long-term ability to secure elite talent around him. Meanwhile, New York’s front office demonstrated its willingness to invest in a championship-caliber roster, reinforcing Alonso’s decision to remain with the Mets.

Industry Reactions and Future Implications

Alonso’s choice to stay in New York was met with mixed reactions from analysts and insiders. Some believed that he left money on the table, while others commended him for prioritizing loyalty over financial gain. A post from @metsbatflip1 on X, citing MLB journalist Pat Ragazzo on WFAN, echoed the sentiment that Alonso never truly intended to leave the Mets: “Industry sources believe that Pete Alonso was never serious about joining the Blue Jays—if he wanted to leave, he would have signed already. His heart was always in New York.”

Moving forward, Alonso’s short-term deal allows him to re-enter free agency after the 2025 season, where he could seek a more lucrative, long-term contract depending on his performance and the state of the Mets’ roster. For now, his commitment to the Mets solidifies his standing as a franchise icon and keeps fans excited for what’s ahead.

Conclusion: Alonso’s Decision Reflects More Than Money

Pete Alonso’s rejection of a higher-value contract from the Blue Jays in favor of staying with the Mets is a testament to his deep connection with the franchise, the city, and the fans. His decision was influenced by his desire to continue competing in a high-profile market, the team’s commitment to winning, and the opportunity to build a lasting legacy in New York. While the Blue Jays made an aggressive push, Alonso’s heart remained in Queens—a decision that will shape the Mets’ future for years to come.