Pete Alonso Reveals Retirement Plans as Mets Prepare to Make 24 Million Decision!

Pete Alonso, affectionately known as the “Polar Bear,” has never been one to shy away from the spotlight or from pressure-packed moments. Since breaking onto the scene in 2019 with a record-setting rookie campaign, Alonso has been the heartbeat of the New York Mets’ offense. Now, at 30 years old and approaching some significant milestones, the slugger has opened up about both his future with the Mets and his eventual retirement, offering a rare look at how a modern baseball star views career longevity, legacy, and business.

As the Mets prepare for a critical $24 million player option decision that could shape their future, Alonso has dropped a major reveal — not only does he plan to test free agency, but he’s already envisioning life after baseball.

A Legacy in the Making

Drafted 64th overall in 2016, Pete Alonso has far outperformed expectations, quickly developing into one of the most feared power hitters in Major League Baseball. On Saturday, he hit his 250th career home run, putting him just two shy of Darryl Strawberry’s franchise record. That milestone is within striking distance, and it’s only a matter of time before Alonso becomes the all-time home run leader in Mets history.

In an interview with MLB.com’s Anthony DiComo, Alonso reflected on his Mets legacy, stating:

“What I want to be remembered as is a player of substance. I just want to be remembered as a guy who plays the game hard, the guy who’s, like, the ultimate competitor. I want to be known as a guy that performs and plays the game and wins.”

That mindset has served him well. Since his debut in 2019, Alonso has launched at least 34 home runs every season — except for the pandemic-shortened 2020 season. In 2025, through 112 games, he has already slugged 24 homers and ranks fourth in MLB with 86 RBIs.

$24 Million Decision Looms Large

Despite his production and value to the Mets, Alonso is not guaranteed to remain in Queens past 2025. He is currently playing under a two-year, $54 million contract signed as a bridge deal. That deal includes a $24 million player option for 2026, which Alonso is expected to decline in search of a long-term contract.

DiComo reported that Alonso has treated the short-term contract as a stepping stone toward a bigger payday:

“From the day he reported to Spring Training in February, Alonso began referencing his newly signed two-year, $54 million deal as ‘kind of like a bridge thing just to get to the next contract.’ He all but said he planned to break Strawberry’s record, then opt out.”

Alonso has made it clear that he values long-term stability. In the same interview, he revealed his retirement timeline, stating that he wants to play until age 40 and then walk away from the game:

“And then at 41, I’ll be done.”

That would suggest he’s aiming for a 10-year deal this offseason — a massive commitment for any team, but one that might be justified considering his track record and durability.

Mets on the Clock

With Alonso’s intentions made clear, the ball is now in the Mets’ court. They’ll need to decide whether to commit big money to their homegrown star or risk letting him walk in free agency. It’s not a simple decision. While Alonso has been a model of consistency and leadership, the Mets also made a massive financial commitment last offseason when they acquired superstar Juan Soto.

Committing to two high-priced sluggers in back-to-back offseasons would place significant strain on the payroll, but it may be the cost of doing business for a team aiming to win now. Letting Alonso leave would also send a disheartening message to the fan base and could disrupt clubhouse chemistry.

What Would Losing Alonso Mean?

If Alonso were to leave, the Mets would lose more than just a powerful bat. They’d be losing a franchise face, a leader in the locker room, and one of the most marketable players in baseball. Alonso has long been a fan favorite, both for his on-field exploits and his off-field charisma. His “Polar Bear” persona is beloved in Queens, and his presence has helped anchor a team that’s been through many ups and downs over the past several seasons.

Replacing that kind of production and leadership would not be easy. While the Mets have promising prospects in the pipeline and the financial power to attract free agents, there is no guarantee they could find another Alonso.

Free Agency Bidding War Looms

If Alonso does hit the open market, expect a feeding frenzy from rival teams. Power-hitting first basemen with elite production and clubhouse presence are rare. The Chicago Cubs, San Francisco Giants, Boston Red Sox, and Seattle Mariners are just a few teams that could make a strong pitch for Alonso’s services.

Given his consistent power, relatively low injury history, and competitive edge, Alonso could easily command $250-300 million over 10 years in free agency. That kind of price tag might scare off some clubs, but others will see it as a worthy investment.

Playing Through 40: Is It Realistic?

Alonso’s declaration that he plans to retire at 41 suggests he sees himself playing 10 more seasons, but doing so at a high level requires health, motivation, and adaptability. While some sluggers have maintained their form into their late 30s — think Nelson Cruz or David Ortiz — the challenge remains steep.

Still, Alonso’s current physical condition and consistent production indicate he’s in it for the long haul. If he can adapt over the years — perhaps by transitioning into a DH role or managing his workload — there’s reason to believe he can achieve that goal.

Conclusion: The Mets’ Franchise Decision

As the New York Mets approach a pivotal offseason, the Pete Alonso situation looms large. Do they back up the truck and sign him to a decade-long deal, securing their franchise cornerstone through the twilight of his career? Or do they let him walk and hope someone else can fill the massive void?

One thing is certain: Pete Alonso has earned the right to make his choice. From a mid-round draft pick to the verge of Mets immortality, he’s done it all with power, passion, and professionalism. Whether in Queens or elsewhere, Alonso’s story is far from over — but the next chapter will be written very soon.