Fans Begged for Her to Play Wonder Woman for 10 Years — Alexandra Daddario Finally Speaks Out

A Dream Cast That Would Not Die

For over a decade, one fan-casting idea refused to fade. Before studios announced anything, before casting directors made their official decisions, the internet already had a favorite. Long before the role of Wonder Woman was formally given to any actress, the online world had chosen their Amazon warrior.

Her name was Alexandra Daddario.

Ever since the early 2010s, fan pages, concept posters, and Reddit threads overflowed with digital art and petitions begging Warner Bros. to cast the rising actress as the iconic superhero. From her piercing blue eyes to her statuesque frame and strong screen presence, everything about her seemed made for the role.

And yet, the phone call never came.

For ten years, Alexandra Daddario said nothing publicly about it. While her name trended every time new rumors surfaced about a Wonder Woman reboot, she stayed silent.

Until now.

Why Now

This week, during a rare in-depth interview with an independent film magazine, Alexandra Daddario finally addressed the fan movement that has followed her for a decade. The discussion started with her latest project, a dark indie thriller set to premiere later this year, but quickly turned toward fan culture and superhero casting.

When the interviewer mentioned her being the internet’s top pick for Wonder Woman for over ten years, she paused. Then smiled.

“I know. I’ve seen it all,” she said. “It’s impossible not to. My face is in a hundred pieces of fan art. I’ve seen the trailers people edited. I’ve seen the fake posters. I’ve even been tagged in petitions.”

And then, after a beat, she added something that surprised everyone.

“I actually auditioned. More than once.”

The Audition That Never Leaked

According to Alexandra Daddario, she read for the role of Diana Prince during the early stages of casting for Batman v Superman. She did not share exact details due to NDAs, but she confirmed that she was brought in for more than one round of screen tests.

“It was exciting,” she admitted. “The scale of it. The possibility. I mean, what actress wouldn’t want to play Wonder Woman? It’s a role with history, power, and depth.”

So why was she never cast

She answered carefully.

“These decisions are never just about acting. They’re about timing. About what a studio sees as bankable. About chemistry with other actors, future contracts, even politics.”

In the end, the role went to Gal Gadot, and history was made. But for many fans, especially those who had championed Daddario since the Percy Jackson days, the casting still felt like a missed opportunity.

And apparently, Daddario felt it too.

“Of course I was disappointed. But I was also grateful. Because being considered for something that massive—that alone is a win.”

Living in the Shadow of a Role She Never Had

Even though she was never cast as Wonder Woman, the shadow of the character seemed to follow Alexandra Daddario throughout her career. Every time a superhero film was announced, her name trended again. Fan-made trailers using clips from her action movies surfaced on YouTube with millions of views. People continued to ask, “Why not her?”

“It’s strange,” she admitted. “It’s like people decided who I was supposed to be before I even figured it out myself.”

That level of public expectation can be flattering. But it can also be heavy.

“There were times when it made me question my real path. Like, if people only wanted me to be this one thing, what happens when I’m not that? Do they stop watching? Do they stop listening?”

She nodded softly before adding, “Eventually, I had to let it go. Because that role didn’t define me. And I had to stop letting the version of me people imagined distract me from the version of me that’s real.”

What She Thinks of Gal Gadot

When asked about Gal Gadot’s performance as Wonder Woman, Alexandra Daddario had nothing but praise.

“I think Gal did a beautiful job. She brought strength and elegance to the role. And honestly, she made it her own. It would’ve been a very different movie if I had done it. Maybe too different.”

She also addressed the fan base’s habit of pitting actresses against each other in superhero roles.

“We don’t have to act like there’s only room for one woman in the room,” she said. “I think there’s space for many versions of strength. And many kinds of heroines.”

This statement alone won her even more admiration among both fans and industry colleagues.

The Reboot Rumors and Fan Pressure

Recently, rumors have swirled about a Wonder Woman reboot under the new DCU leadership. With Gal Gadot’s future uncertain and the franchise moving in a new direction, fan campaigns have once again reignited the call for Alexandra Daddario to step into the boots.

The hashtags returned. New posters were created. YouTube exploded with fresh edits.

So what does Daddario think about it now

Her answer was both honest and grounded.

“Would I say yes if it was offered?” Maybe. Maybe not. It depends on what the project stands for. Who’s behind it? What kind of story they’re telling. And whether or not I believe in the version of Diana they want to bring to life.”

She added one more thing.

“I spent a long time thinking I missed my shot. But maybe that was never really my shot to begin with. Maybe what’s coming next is something even better. Something no one’s written yet.”

Fans React to Her Revelation

Following the release of the interview, social media once again lit up. But this time, the conversation was different. It wasn’t just about fan casting or what might have been. It was about respect.

Thousands of posts praised Alexandra Daddario’s humility and insight. Others acknowledged how rare it is for an actor to speak candidly about missed opportunities without bitterness.

One post read, “She’s Wonder Woman in energy even if she never wears the costume. Grace. Power. Honesty.”

Another added, “She may not be Diana. But she’s leading her own revolution now.”

And for many fans, this honest reflection was more satisfying than any costume reveal.

A Bigger Message About Typecasting and Fan Ownership

What this entire situation reveals is how fan expectations can sometimes shape—and distort—an actor’s trajectory. For ten years, Alexandra Daddario was imagined, Photoshopped, and petitioned into a role she never officially owned. And while the passion of that fanbase is undeniable, it also points to a deeper issue in modern entertainment.

Sometimes, we are so obsessed with what an actor could be, we fail to appreciate what they already are.

Daddario’s choice to finally speak out—and to do so with vulnerability instead of frustration—offers a masterclass in navigating celebrity culture with grace.

She reminded her audience that every performer is more than just the roles they didn’t get. They are more than an algorithm of appearance plus popularity.

And most importantly, they are human.

It took ten years for Alexandra Daddario to finally speak on the role that fans never let her forget. And when she did, she did not offer scandal. She did not attack the studio or the process. She did not dwell on what might have been.

She told the truth. With maturity. With nuance. With clarity.

And in doing so, she may have finally closed the chapter on a conversation that was never really hers to begin with.

Because while the world waited to see her as Wonder Woman, Alexandra Daddario was busy becoming something more powerful

Herself.