Sabrina Carpenter’s Sexy Album Dominates the Charts — But Taylor Swift’s Fans Are Furious Over Who Got Knocked Down!
When Sabrina Carpenter teased her upcoming album Man’s Best Friend, no one could have predicted it would shake the charts even before its release. But now, with Spotify pre-saves placing her at #1, Carpenter has officially outpaced Taylor Swift’s highly anticipated The Life of a Showgirl, scheduled to drop later this year.
And the internet is losing its mind. Some fans are celebrating Carpenter’s breakout success, while others are furious — especially Swifties who feel their queen has been knocked down from her throne. What really happened, why is this chart battle making headlines, and how will it impact both stars? Let’s dive deep into the biggest pop rivalry of 2025.
How Sabrina Carpenter Beat Taylor Swift at Her Own Game
On August 29, 2025, Man’s Best Friend will officially hit streaming platforms, but the hype has already surpassed industry expectations. According to Spotify Pre-Saves rankings, Carpenter’s album currently sits at #1, while Taylor Swift’s The Life of a Showgirl, expected to release October 3, sits just behind at #2. Meanwhile,
Ed Sheeran’s Play, dropping on September 12, takes the #3 spot. For a young pop star like Carpenter to outrank music’s most dominant figure is a seismic shift. It’s not just about numbers — it’s about what this means for the future of pop’s hierarchy. Has Sabrina Carpenter finally broken out of Taylor Swift’s shadow, or is this simply a pre-release spike fueled by online buzz?
The Album That Shook the Internet
The lead single, “Manchild”, released June 6, already stirred conversations. Co-written and co-produced with Jack Antonoff — a name closely tied to Swift — the collaboration sent shockwaves through fan communities. Carpenter also worked with Amy Allen, known for hits with Shawn Mendes and Halsey.
The result? A sultry, satirical, and polarizing track that positioned Carpenter as both a pop provocateur and a rising force in the songwriting arena. The album artwork added more fuel to the fire. Some criticized it for pandering to the male gaze, while others argued it was a clever critique of purity culture. The controversy only boosted the album’s visibility, making it impossible to ignore.
As one fan put it bluntly: “Omg she didn’t change the album cover?? Gross. I hate that picture.” And yet, another countered: “I love that Sabrina didn’t change the cover. Go girl!” The clash of opinions turned the release into a cultural flashpoint — exactly the type of buzz every label dreams of.
Tracklist Reveals a Pop Narrative Fans Can’t Stop Talking About
The 12-song lineup for Man’s Best Friend reads like an emotional rollercoaster:
-
Manchild
-
Tears
-
My Man on Willpower
-
Sugar Talking
-
We Almost Broke Up Again Last Night
-
Nobody’s Son
-
Never Getting Laid
-
When Did You Get Hot?
-
Go Go Juice
-
Don’t Worry, I’ll Make You Worry
-
House Tour
-
Goodbye
Just from the titles, it’s clear Carpenter isn’t playing it safe. Provocative names like “Never Getting Laid” and “When Did You Get Hot?” practically scream viral content. Each track suggests a mix of humor, heartbreak, and self-awareness, ensuring fans will dissect every lyric for hidden meanings once the album drops.
The Intimate Fan Event That Took Everyone by Surprise
If chart numbers and controversies weren’t enough, Carpenter added another clever PR move: an exclusive album playdate on August 15. She invited 26 fans from Los Angeles into her studio, where she played Man’s Best Friend in full. Videos and social media posts from the event quickly spread, turning those attendees into brand ambassadors.
What better way to build anticipation than letting your most loyal fans become the first to hear the album? This grassroots tactic contrasts with Swift’s large-scale rollouts and proves Carpenter knows how to cultivate intimacy in an industry often accused of being too polished.
Taylor Swift’s Shadow Still Looms Large
Here’s where the drama gets juicier: despite being “rivals” in headlines, Carpenter will actually feature on the title track of Taylor Swift’s The Life of a Showgirl.
Yes, the same artist currently outranking Swift in pre-saves is also collaborating with her. This dual role has left fans divided. Some call it “a passing of the torch”, while others see it as calculated positioning by Swift to ensure she remains at the center of the conversation. For now, Carpenter is riding high, but when Swift’s album finally drops in October, the narrative could flip overnight. Will Sabrina’s success be remembered as a historic upset, or just a temporary pop culture blip?
Fan Reactions: Divided but Loud
As with every pop rivalry, fan reactions online are split:
-
“lol I’m a fan of both and I’ve pre-saved neither of them.”
-
“Excited for this album.”
-
“Can we stop pitting Taylor and Sabrina against each other? Both can be celebrated!”
Some fans want unity, but the media thrives on division. Every headline that frames Carpenter vs. Swift only fuels the drama, making the story impossible to escape.
Why This Rivalry Could Define 2025 Pop Culture
In many ways, this isn’t just about Spotify pre-saves. It’s about the larger narrative of women in pop music and how the industry frames them.
We’ve seen it before — Britney vs. Christina, Gaga vs. Katy, Taylor vs. Katy, and now Taylor vs. Sabrina. What makes this moment unique is that Carpenter is no longer just a supporting act. With hits like “Espresso” already dominating, and now with Man’s Best Friend ready to set records, she’s proving she can go toe-to-toe with the biggest names in music. The question is: can she sustain it? Or will Swift’s October release reestablish her dominance and remind everyone why she’s the reigning queen of pop?
Final Thoughts: A Pop Showdown for the Ages
Man’s Best Friend isn’t just another pop album — it’s a cultural moment. By beating Taylor Swift in pre-saves, Sabrina Carpenter has stepped into the spotlight in a way no one expected.
From provocative track titles to bold artistic choices, she’s daring to challenge conventions and, in the process, sparking one of the most talked-about rivalries of the year. Whether you’re Team Swift, Team Carpenter, or simply a fan of pop drama, one thing is certain: August 29 and October 3 are dates that will define the 2025 music calendar. Until then, the internet will keep buzzing, fans will keep debating, and the music industry will keep watching — because the throne of pop has never felt more fragile.
