Tony Pollard vs. Tyjae Spears: Who to Draft in Fantasy Football?

As the Tennessee Titans prepare for the upcoming NFL season, the spotlight is on their dynamic running back duo: Tony Pollard and Tyjae Spears. With new head coach Brian Callahan at the helm, the team’s offensive strategy is set to undergo a significant transformation. This raises an important question for fantasy football enthusiasts: who should you draft, Pollard or Spears?

A New Offensive Approach

Brian Callahan comes to the Titans after a successful tenure as the offensive coordinator for the Cincinnati Bengals, where he consistently ranked among the top five in pass rate. Under Callahan, the Bengals maintained a fast-paced offense, running more plays per game compared to the Titans, who have traditionally leaned on a ground-heavy strategy with Derrick Henry. With Callahan’s leadership, the Titans are projected to adopt a more up-tempo offense, leading to an expected increase in passing volume. According to ESPN’s Mike Clay, the Titans could have the highest pass rate in the league, coupled with a 5% increase in total plays compared to the previous season. This bodes well for both Pollard and Spears, creating more opportunities for targets and touchdowns.

Minimal Competition for Touches

The Titans’ backfield presents a favorable situation for Pollard and Spears. They face minimal competition for carries, as the fight for the third running back spot involves Hassan Haskins, Julius Chestnut, and Jabari Small, who collectively have just 34 career rushing attempts. Callahan has made it clear that both Pollard and Spears are viewed as starting players, further solidifying their roles in the offense.

Workload Split: Who Gets the Ball?

The Titans plan to utilize a “hot hand” approach, allowing Pollard and Spears to share backfield touches. This strategy plays to the strengths of both players, as they bring different skills to the table. Pollard has proven he can handle a heavy workload, finishing seventh in the league for rushing attempts last season and third in yards after contact. Given the Titans’ struggles with run blocking, especially on the right side of their offensive line, Pollard is favored to secure a majority of the carries, utilizing his ability to generate yards after contact.

On the other hand, Spears displayed his potential last year in a limited role, boasting a higher rate of explosive runs (15+ yards) and more yards per carry compared to Pollard. His efficiency and ability to make plays in space could lead to increased targets and receptions, making him a valuable asset in a more balanced offense.

Goal Line Opportunities

Both running backs are expected to see goal-line carries throughout the season, particularly as the Titans may rotate series between them. Pollard, with a weight advantage of 14 pounds, was only stuffed in short-yardage situations 24% of the time last season, compared to Spears’ 29%. While Spears may have more scoring opportunities through the air, Pollard is likely to lead the team in red zone carries, giving him an edge in total touchdowns.

Making Your Choice

Both Tony Pollard and Tyjae Spears present compelling cases for fantasy football drafts. Pollard’s experience and ability to churn out tough yards make him a reliable choice, while Spears’ explosiveness and efficiency could offer significant upside, especially in PPR leagues. Ultimately, your decision may hinge on your draft strategy and the depth of your roster. As the Titans embrace a new offensive philosophy, both players are set to play pivotal roles, making them essential considerations for fantasy owners this season.