What’s Next for Pete Alonso? Steve Cohen Finally Breaks Silence on the Slugger’s Future with the New York Mets

The 2025 MLB season has brought new life to the New York Mets—but it has also reopened a lingering question: What is the future of Pete Alonso? One of the league’s most consistent power hitters and a beloved figure in Queens, Alonso has yet to confirm whether he will stay long-term with the Mets. Adding fuel to the fire, Mets owner Steve Cohen recently addressed the situation publicly, sparking waves of speculation among fans, media, and baseball insiders.

Pete Alonso’s Contract Keeps the Door Wide Open

When Pete Alonso signed a two-year deal with the New York Mets ahead of the 2025 season, many assumed it was a stepping stone—one that allowed the first baseman flexibility. The contract includes a player opt-out clause after the first year, which means Alonso could hit free agency at the end of the season if he believes the market will reward him more handsomely. This has only increased interest in what happens next.

From a financial standpoint, Alonso’s current deal is already generous, but for a player of his caliber, the potential for a longer, more lucrative contract looms large. He’s on pace to put up numbers that could demand a mega-deal—and Mets fans are wondering if Steve Cohen is willing to meet that price.

Steve Cohen Speaks—But Doesn’t Settle Anything

Steve Cohen’s recent comments have added clarity—but also complexity—to the situation. In addressing Alonso’s future, Cohen acknowledged that the decision ultimately rests in the slugger’s hands. He expressed support for Alonso testing his value in the open market but stopped short of saying whether the Mets would aggressively pursue an extension before the season ends.

This non-committal stance has been interpreted in several ways. Some believe it shows confidence that Alonso will choose to remain a Met. Others think it signals that the team may be preparing for life without him. What’s clear is that Cohen is leaving the door open, while also buying time to evaluate Alonso’s full 2025 performance.

Pete Alonso’s Red-Hot Start Puts Pressure on Mets Front Office

There’s no denying Pete Alonso is making a compelling case for long-term investment. Through the first month of the season, he’s been on fire. With a batting average north of .330, six home runs, and nearly 30 RBIs, Alonso has been a major driver behind the Mets’ impressive early-season surge.

The Mets currently lead the league in wins, and Alonso’s bat is a big reason why. His chemistry with the rest of the lineup, particularly in the clutch, has been undeniable. And his ability to deliver under pressure makes him one of the most valuable assets in the National League. Every home run he hits and every run he drives in adds another zero to his next contract.

Negotiation Drama: Why This Won’t Be Easy

Negotiations with top-tier talent are never simple—and Alonso’s situation is no exception. It’s no secret that his last round of contract talks with the Mets was emotionally taxing for both sides. While the result was a high-value deal, it didn’t come easily. Alonso’s camp wants a long-term commitment that reflects his status as one of the game’s elite hitters, while the Mets may be hesitant to tie up future payroll flexibility.

There are also structural disagreements. Should the Mets offer an opt-out clause in a long-term deal? How many years are they willing to guarantee? Will they consider creative bonuses, incentives, or front-loaded money to keep the slugger satisfied? These questions will define the tone of negotiations later this year—assuming Alonso doesn’t opt to walk away.

Insurance Plan: Who Could Replace Alonso if He Leaves?

While the team hasn’t made any official statements about contingency plans, there are signs that the Mets are preparing for any outcome. Younger players like Mark Vientos and Brett Baty, typically third basemen, have reportedly been training at first base in practice. This suggests the front office is actively working on backup options.

Still, neither of those names offers Alonso’s elite power or fan appeal. Losing Alonso would create a massive hole in the lineup and in the team’s identity. While developing internal talent is important, there is no real substitute for a player of Alonso’s caliber. That’s why retaining him may be as much a branding decision as a baseball one.

The Fan Factor: Alonso Means More Than Just Numbers

Pete Alonso isn’t just a slugger—he’s a symbol of hope for Mets fans. Since debuting in 2019 and smashing the rookie home run record, he has carried the torch for a franchise that often teeters between mediocrity and greatness. He brings fire, leadership, and humility to the clubhouse, and he’s one of the few players who can energize Citi Field with a single swing.

Letting him walk would not only hurt the team’s chances on the field but would also risk alienating a passionate fanbase. Fans see Alonso as one of their own. He’s made charitable donations, spoken out about causes that matter to him, and never distanced himself from the community. For Mets fans, he’s not just the first baseman—he’s their first baseman.

Why Free Agency Could Be Inevitable

Even if Alonso wants to stay with the Mets, there’s a growing sense that he’ll still test the open market. With his current form and a relatively light free-agent class next winter, he could attract enormous offers from other franchises. Teams like the San Francisco Giants, Chicago Cubs, or even the Boston Red Sox could see Alonso as the missing piece.

That said, Alonso’s loyalty to the Mets shouldn’t be underestimated. He’s frequently stated how much he enjoys playing in New York. But in baseball, loyalty and business don’t always align. If another team comes to the table with a record-breaking offer, the Mets will have to decide how far they’re willing to go.

A Risk the Mets Can’t Afford?

Letting Alonso walk after a monster season would send shockwaves through the league—and likely damage the Mets’ credibility among fans. After investing in big names and building a competitive roster, losing their star slugger would be a major step backward. It could also deter future free agents from seeing the Mets as a team committed to keeping their top talent.

Steve Cohen is known as an owner who’s willing to spend to win. But he’s also shown discipline when it comes to making long-term financial commitments. This balance of aggression and caution will be put to the test in the Alonso negotiations. The risk of letting him go might outweigh the financial cost of keeping him.

What Needs to Happen Next

The Mets and Alonso should aim to start serious negotiations before the end of the 2025 season. Waiting until free agency opens the door for aggressive poaching from other franchises. If the team truly wants to keep him in New York for the long haul, they need to act while Alonso’s focus is still on helping them win.

A multi-year deal in the range of 7–8 years with performance bonuses, club options, and a partial no-trade clause might offer enough flexibility for both parties. The key is making Alonso feel valued—not just as a player, but as a leader and symbol of the franchise.

Final Thoughts: A Defining Decision Awaits

The future of Pete Alonso with the New York Mets will be one of the defining storylines of the 2025 MLB season. With Steve Cohen now publicly acknowledging the uncertainty, all eyes will be on how the front office handles the situation moving forward. For fans, this isn’t just about home runs—it’s about identity, trust, and the belief that the Mets are building something sustainable.

If the Mets want to win both on the field and in the hearts of fans, re-signing Pete Alonso may be the most important move they can make. Because sometimes, keeping your homegrown star is the best way to build a championship legacy.