Wednesday Star Jenna Ortega’s First Date Horror Story Will Make You Cringe…and Laugh!

Netflix’s breakout star Jenna Ortega, best known for her captivating role as Wednesday Addams in the hit series Wednesday, recently opened up about her worst first date experience in an exclusive interview with ELLE UK. Despite playing a character who thrives in eerie and spooky situations on screen, Ortega’s real-life dating stories are far from supernatural—they are downright relatable and awkward.

As fans continue to eagerly binge Wednesday Season 2, with part two dropping on September 3, 2025, Jenna Ortega’s charming personality and candid anecdotes are reminding us why she’s not only a phenomenal actress but also incredibly down-to-earth. This article delves into Jenna’s memorable first date story, shares insights from her co-stars, and explores how her personal experiences contrast with her enigmatic on-screen persona.

Jenna Ortega’s Rise to Stardom as Wednesday Addams

Before we dive into the details of her hilarious date, it’s important to acknowledge Jenna Ortega’s meteoric rise as the face of Netflix’s Wednesday. Since its debut, the series has captured millions of viewers worldwide, propelled by Ortega’s deadpan wit and unique portrayal of the iconic Wednesday Addams character.

The second installment of the series, released in two parts (August 6 and September 3, 2025), has only amplified the buzz. Jenna’s portrayal continues to evolve, drawing praise for how she blends mystery, humor, and vulnerability. Yet, beyond the spooky narrative of Nevermore Academy, Jenna’s candid personality shines in interviews, showcasing a side of her fans rarely see on screen.

The Worst First Date Experience: A Vegetarian’s Dilemma

In a lighthearted interview with ELLE UK, Jenna Ortega recounted her worst first date—one that any vegetarian might cringe at but many can empathize with. She revealed that her date thoughtfully decided to cook a meal for her, not realizing she was vegetarian.

“One time, I was on this date and they had cooked. I’m vegetarian and they didn’t know that I didn’t eat meat,” Jenna shared with a laugh.

Rather than awkwardly correcting her date or making a fuss, Jenna admitted to quietly eating a couple of bites out of politeness, despite feeling uncomfortable.

“Rather than say anything, I just had a couple of bites because I just felt bad,” she said. “I never told them, I just never saw them again.”

This story perfectly captures Jenna’s blend of kindness and humor—choosing to avoid confrontation, and ultimately deciding that the date wasn’t meant to be. It’s a charmingly relatable moment that humanizes a star who often seems larger than life.

Jenna Ortega’s Authenticity Resonates With Fans

This candid revelation of Jenna’s worst first date experience offers fans a rare glimpse of her personal life outside the gothic allure of Wednesday. Ortega’s willingness to share such an awkward but genuine moment endears her even more to her audience.

In a world where celebrity stories often feel overly polished, Jenna’s down-to-earth personality shines through. Her story reminds fans that even stars face everyday mishaps—whether it’s navigating dietary preferences or handling uncomfortable social situations.

It’s no surprise that Wednesday fans continue to adore Jenna not just for her talent but for her relatable, approachable nature.

Co-Stars Emma Myers and Joy Sunday Share Their Awkward Dating Stories

Jenna Ortega wasn’t alone in dishing about cringe-worthy first dates. During the same interview, her Wednesday co-stars Emma Myers (who plays Enid Sinclair) and Joy Sunday (Bianca Barclay) also shared their own hilarious experiences.

Emma Myers admitted to numerous first dates where she wasn’t even sure it was a date:

“Lots of first dates that I didn’t realise were a date. I panic.”

Joy Sunday added to the fun, saying:

“You just keep going as if it’s not a date.”

These stories highlight a universal truth: first dates can often be confusing and awkward, no matter who you are. This playful camaraderie between the Wednesday cast not only deepens fans’ connection to the show but also provides a light-hearted counterbalance to the series’ dark themes.

How Jenna Ortega’s Off-Screen Personality Enhances Wednesday

The contrast between Jenna Ortega’s real-life experiences and her onscreen character Wednesday Addams underscores her impressive range as an actress. While Wednesday is known for her stoic, morbid demeanor, Jenna’s interviews reveal warmth, humor, and vulnerability.

This authenticity makes her portrayal even more compelling, as she brings subtle emotional depth to a character traditionally portrayed as one-dimensional and gothic. The genuine charm Jenna exhibits off-screen likely contributes to why the audience connects so deeply with Wednesday.

As Wednesday Season 2 continues to garner views, fans eagerly anticipate more of Jenna’s nuanced performances and candid moments.

The Cultural Impact of Wednesday and Jenna Ortega’s Stardom

Since its premiere, Wednesday has become a cultural phenomenon, blending mystery, supernatural elements, and teenage drama into a unique package. Jenna Ortega’s breakout role has propelled her into the spotlight, making her one of the most talked-about young actresses in Hollywood.

Her relatability, as demonstrated by sharing personal stories like her worst first date, plays a big role in this widespread appeal. Fans see her as not just a talented star but someone they can identify with beyond the screen.

This connection helps explain the massive anticipation around Wednesday Season 2, which dropped its second half on September 3, 2025, continuing to break streaming records.

Behind the Scenes: Jenna’s Friendship with Co-Stars and Celebrities

Beyond her on-screen work and interviews, Jenna Ortega’s vibrant social media presence shows her close bonds with co-stars Emma Myers and Joy Sunday. The trio often shares behind-the-scenes moments from Wednesday, including candid snaps and playful interactions, which further humanize the cast and invite fans into their world.

Additionally, Jenna’s friendship with industry icons like Lady Gaga—who stars as Morticia Addams in the series—adds another layer to her rising profile. This network of support highlights how Jenna is navigating her career with both professionalism and genuine warmth.

What’s Next for Jenna Ortega and Wednesday?

As Wednesday Season 2 continues to captivate audiences worldwide, Jenna Ortega’s star shows no signs of dimming. Rumors of a Wednesday Season 3 have already sparked excitement, with fans eager to see how her character develops.

Jenna’s willingness to share personal stories like her worst first date experience adds to the excitement, making viewers feel more connected to her journey both on and off screen.

Final Thoughts: Jenna Ortega’s Worst First Date is a Reminder We’re All Human

In the end, Jenna Ortega’s story about awkwardly eating meat on a first date is a delightful reminder that no one is perfect—celebrity or not. It’s these moments of vulnerability and humor that make her so beloved.

As fans dive deeper into Wednesday’s spooky world, it’s comforting to know that Jenna Ortega remains refreshingly relatable, balancing her rising fame with stories we can all laugh about.