Pete Alonso is predicted to leave the Mets with a $240 million deal.

As the 2025 MLB season unfolds, Pete Alonso is once again proving why he’s among the most powerful and valuable hitters in the game. But while the New York Mets are enjoying his explosive bat, a storm may be brewing behind the scenes. According to several insiders, Pete Alonso is predicted to leave the Mets, potentially signing a massive $240 million deal with a new franchise in free agency. This development has ignited fierce speculation, emotional reactions from fans, and major implications for the future of the Mets organization.

A Superstar’s Worth: Why Pete Alonso Deserves $240 Million

Pete Alonso has earned his nickname “The Polar Bear” not just for his size and power, but for his consistency and dedication since debuting in 2019. As of 2025, he remains the centerpiece of the Mets’ offense, delivering home runs, RBIs, and leadership at an elite level.

• Alonso has already eclipsed the 230 career home run mark and is on pace to break Darryl Strawberry’s Mets record of 252 home runs by midseason.

• His current season slash line (.289/.376/.615) puts him in elite company with players like Shohei Ohtani and Aaron Judge.

• He has been selected to multiple All-Star Games, won a Home Run Derby, and was pivotal in keeping the Mets competitive during rebuilding years.

Given this resume, a $240 million contract isn’t a stretch—it’s market value for a first baseman of his caliber. With teams flush with revenue and desperate for power hitters, Alonso’s name is at the top of every front office’s wish list.

Contract Drama: Why the Mets May Lose Pete Alonso

Despite Alonso’s value, the New York Mets front office has been slow to lock him down with a long-term deal. This hesitancy has opened the door for speculation and, now, potential offers from other teams.

• Alonso is set to become a free agent after the 2025 season, and while extension talks reportedly occurred last year, no agreement was reached.

• Insiders claim Alonso is looking for a deal in the range of 8 years, $240 million, citing comparable contracts like Freddie Freeman’s six-year deal with the Dodgers and Paul Goldschmidt’s extension with the Cardinals.

• Mets ownership, led by Steve Cohen, has spent big in recent years but may hesitate to commit such a massive sum to a first baseman nearing 31.

“I want to be here,” Alonso said earlier this season, “but I also want to be valued for what I bring. This is my prime—I won’t compromise.”

The tension is rising. If no extension is signed by midseason, expect trade rumors and free agency buzz to dominate headlines.

Potential Landing Spots: Who Could Sign Pete Alonso?

If Pete Alonso leaves the Mets, a number of teams are expected to pursue him aggressively, especially those with playoff ambitions and payroll flexibility.

1. Chicago Cubs – The Cubs have been linked to Alonso repeatedly, and they have the financial power to offer a $240 million contract. With a strong young core, Alonso could be the veteran slugger that takes them deep into October.

2. Seattle Mariners – With a glaring need for middle-of-the-lineup power, the Mariners could jump in. They’ve been active in recent winters and need a big name to anchor their offense.

3. San Francisco Giants – The Giants missed out on Ohtani and Judge in previous offseasons. Landing Pete Alonso would not only deliver power but also send a message to fans that they’re serious about contending.

4. Boston Red Sox – Always active in free agency, the Red Sox have a hole at first base and money to spend. Alonso’s right-handed power would be lethal in Fenway Park.

All of these teams are expected to have interest, but the final offer may exceed $240 million, especially if Alonso finishes the 2025 season with another 40+ home runs.

Mets Fans React: Fear, Frustration, and Pleas for Retention

The possibility of Pete Alonso leaving the Mets has shaken the fan base. For many, he represents the heart and soul of the team, a homegrown superstar who embraced New York and delivered in pressure moments.

• On social media, Mets fans have been vocal with hashtags like #KeepPete and #PayThePolarBear, urging the team to offer a fair contract before it’s too late.

• At Citi Field, signs and chants have echoed the sentiment, with crowds cheering louder than ever when Alonso steps to the plate.

• Talk radio and podcasts have exploded with debate, with many blaming the front office for dragging its feet on one of the most critical negotiations in recent team history.

“If we let Alonso walk, we’re sending the wrong message,” said one caller on WFAN. “This guy is everything we want in a Met. Pay him!”

The emotional attachment between Alonso and the fan base runs deep—losing him could cause not just a talent drain, but a morale crisis in Queens.

Strategic Risks: What Happens if the Mets Let Alonso Walk?

From a baseball operations standpoint, letting Pete Alonso walk in free agency would carry serious consequences for the Mets.

• The team would lose its most consistent power hitter and a clubhouse leader. Replacing that kind of presence is extremely difficult, even with money.

• The Mets farm system doesn’t currently have a first baseman ready to step into Alonso’s shoes, making the void even larger.

• In terms of branding and revenue, Alonso’s departure could hurt ticket sales, jersey sales, and public perception, especially after investing heavily in other aging stars.

• Team chemistry could suffer as younger players who look up to Alonso might feel demoralized or less confident in the front office’s commitment to winning.

Unless the Mets are able to swing a blockbuster trade or sign another superstar to fill the void, the risk of letting Alonso walk could backfire spectacularly.

How Alonso’s Market Compares to MLB’s Recent Mega Deals

A $240 million deal for Pete Alonso would place him among the highest-paid first basemen in MLB history. Let’s look at how it stacks up against recent contracts:

• Paul Goldschmidt (Cardinals): 5 years, $130 million

• Freddie Freeman (Dodgers): 6 years, $162 million

• Matt Olson (Braves): 8 years, $168 million

• Jose Abreu (Astros): 3 years, $58.5 million

Given Alonso’s power numbers and consistent production, a deal in the range of 8 years, $240 million would not only reflect market trends—it might actually be a bargain when factoring in his age and projected WAR (Wins Above Replacement).

If he maintains elite performance through 2030, he could easily outperform his contract, especially with inflation and rising media revenues.

Conclusion: Will the Mets Let a Franchise Legend Walk Away?

The looming possibility that Pete Alonso may leave the Mets for a $240 million payday has created a massive fork in the road for the franchise. Will they pony up and secure one of the game’s top sluggers long-term, or will financial hesitation lead to heartbreak?

For Alonso, the decision may come down to respect, security, and the chance to win a championship. For the Mets, it’s a test of priorities—are they building for sustained excellence, or risking it all by letting their cornerstone slip away?