Miley Cyrus Stuck as She Can’t Escape the Flowers Lawsuit and Liam Hemsworth’s Name

Miley Cyrus’ smash hit “Flowers” might have dominated the charts, but behind the scenes, the song is entangled in a legal battle that just took a turn for the worse for the pop star. A judge has rejected Cyrus’ motion to dismiss a copyright lawsuit against the track, forcing the singer to remain entangled in the dispute over its originality.

The Lawsuit That Just Won’t Go Away

The legal troubles surrounding Flowers began when a songwriter duo claimed that the track bears striking similarities to their lesser-known work. While plagiarism claims are nothing new in the music industry, this particular case has gained traction due to the overwhelming success of Flowers—a song that spent multiple weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 and became an anthem of empowerment and independence.

Miley’s legal team moved swiftly to have the case thrown out, arguing that the claims were unfounded and that any similarities were purely coincidental. However, the judge has now ruled that there is sufficient reason for the case to proceed, meaning Cyrus will have to confront the allegations head-on.

Why Miley Allegedly Wants To Avoid Trial

While legal experts debate the strength of the case, rumors have surfaced that Miley desperately wanted to have the lawsuit dismissed for reasons beyond just copyright concerns. Reports suggest that Cyrus is reluctant to go to trial because it could force her to publicly confirm what fans have suspected all along—that Flowers was directly inspired by her past relationship with Liam Hemsworth.

The breakup of Miley and Liam’s on-and-off romance has been a hot topic for years, and Flowers was widely interpreted as a not-so-subtle jab at her ex-husband. From the Bruno Mars lyric interpolation to the timing of the release (right around Liam’s birthday), fans have dissected every element of the song for hidden messages. However, Cyrus has remained vague about the song’s true inspiration, and sources claim she wants to keep it that way.

A trial could drag personal details into the spotlight that Miley has been trying to leave in the past. Legal proceedings often involve sworn statements and depositions, which means she could be required to address questions about Liam and confirm whether their failed marriage was a direct influence on the track.

Liam Hemsworth’s Silence Speaks Volumes

While Miley is fighting to keep the lawsuit at bay, Liam Hemsworth has remained largely silent on the matter. Unlike some celebrity exes who engage in public feuds, Hemsworth has avoided addressing Flowers directly. However, sources close to him have hinted that he’s well aware of the song’s implications and is not thrilled about being at the center of the controversy once again.

Despite staying quiet, Liam has been making moves to distance himself from the drama. He has been focused on upcoming acting projects and is reportedly in a happy place with his current personal life. If Miley is forced to acknowledge that Flowers was about their relationship, it could add even more strain to an already complicated history between the two.

The Impact On Miley’s Career

Regardless of the lawsuit’s outcome, this controversy could have long-term consequences for Miley’s career. Flowers was praised for its empowering message, and admitting that it was based on her past relationship could shift the narrative in a way she didn’t intend. Instead of being seen as an anthem of self-love, it might be reduced to another breakup song fueled by personal drama.

Additionally, a high-profile trial would likely keep the focus on her past rather than her future music. Miley has been working on new projects and has tried to move beyond the tabloid heavy coverage of her personal life. However, if she’s forced to testify or provide statements, the media cycle could become all about Liam once again.

What’s Next For The Lawsuit?

With the judge refusing to dismiss the case, Miley’s legal team now faces a tough decision. They can either fight the case in court—which comes with risks of exposing personal details—or settle out of court to avoid further public scrutiny.

If the case does go to trial, expect more revelations and heightened speculation about the true inspiration behind Flowers. For now, Miley is left with a legal mess that could have been avoided if the lawsuit had been dismissed—but that’s no longer an option.

The next few months will be critical as Miley either gears up for a legal battle or looks for a way to settle quietly. Either way, this lawsuit is proving to be an unexpected roadblock in what has otherwise been a major career milestone for the pop star.

A History of Legal Battles in the Music Industry

Miley isn’t the first artist to face a lawsuit over alleged song similarities. Many artists, including Ed Sheeran, Robin Thicke, and Katy Perry, have all had to battle copyright claims in court. Some, like Sheeran, managed to win their cases, while others, like Thicke, ended up paying hefty settlements.

One of the most notorious music copyright cases was the “Blurred Lines” lawsuit, in which Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams were ordered to pay $5 million to Marvin Gaye’s estate for similarities to Got to Give It Up. The case set a precedent for future lawsuits and left many artists wary of unintentional similarities in their music.

In the case of Flowers, some experts argue that the claim may not hold up in court, as proving copyright infringement in music requires substantial evidence of direct copying rather than general inspiration. However, with a judge allowing the case to proceed, it seems there is enough legal ground to warrant further examination.

The Emotional Toll on Miley

Beyond the legal and professional risks, sources close to Cyrus claim that the lawsuit is taking an emotional toll on the singer. Despite her bold and confident persona, Miley has been open in the past about struggling with public scrutiny and dealing with the emotional aftermath of her highly publicized breakup with Hemsworth.

If this lawsuit forces her to relive those moments and publicly dissect her personal life again, it could be a major setback for her emotionally. Some insiders suggest that Miley has considered settling the case just to avoid the mental exhaustion of a drawn-out legal battle, even if she believes she would ultimately win.

Public Reaction: Fans Divided

As with any high-profile legal battle, public opinion is sharply divided. Some fans believe that the lawsuit is a cash grab and an attempt to profit off Miley’s success. Others think that the singers bringing the lawsuit have a legitimate case and deserve their day in court.

On social media, discussions about Flowers have reignited, with some users analyzing the similarities to the plaintiffs’ song and others defending Miley, stating that music is inherently repetitive and that artists often draw inspiration from existing sounds.

Final Thoughts

Miley Cyrus may have thought she was done addressing her past with Liam Hemsworth, but the Flowers lawsuit could force her hand. Whether she wins or loses in court, the drama surrounding the song isn’t fading away anytime soon. And for a star who thrives on reinvention, this might be one controversy she wasn’t prepared for.

As the legal battle continues to unfold, one thing is certain: Miley’s fight over Flowers is far from over, and the outcome could reshape not only her narrative but also the broader discussion about music copyright in the modern era.