Is the heavyweight division dying as rumoured? Tom Aspinall ready to make Gane fight his answer!

The UFC heavyweight division has always held a special place in the world of mixed martial arts (MMA). From the days of Randy Couture and Brock Lesnar to the reigns of Stipe Miocic, Francis Ngannou, and now Tom Aspinall, this division has been synonymous with raw power, drama, and unforgettable knockouts. But in recent months, the conversation around the state of the heavyweight division has taken a negative turn.

Prominent UFC commentator and podcast host Joe Rogan expressed his view that the heavyweight division has become “shallow,” particularly if the dream matchup between Tom Aspinall and Jon Jones doesn’t materialize. Many UFC fans echoed these sentiments, arguing that the division lacks depth and compelling contenders compared to lighter weight classes.

In response, Tom Aspinall, the reigning interim heavyweight champion, has stepped forward to defend not only his belt but also the honor of the entire heavyweight roster. In a recent interview, Aspinall countered the criticism, stressing that while the division may not currently boast as many big-name stars, the level of talent is higher than ever, and a new generation of heavyweights is poised to revitalize the scene.

This article takes a deep dive into Aspinall’s defense of the heavyweight division, breaking down the roots of the “shallow” criticism, evaluating the current and emerging stars of the division, and exploring why UFC 321 and beyond could define the next golden era of heavyweight MMA.

The Roots of the “Shallow” Criticism

Joe Rogan’s Comments and Influence

When Joe Rogan speaks, the MMA world listens. His long-standing role as a UFC commentator, combined with the massive reach of his podcast, means his opinions can shape narratives across the sport. Rogan’s suggestion that the heavyweight division is “so shallow” if Tom Aspinall vs Jon Jones doesn’t happen sparked a flurry of debate across social media and MMA forums.

Rogan’s point is rooted in the perception that aside from Aspinall, Jones, and perhaps Ciryl Gane, there are not enough marketable or elite-level heavyweights to keep fans consistently engaged. He emphasized the lack of star power and questioned whether current contenders could carry the torch in a division historically associated with larger-than-life figures.

Fan Sentiments

Fans on platforms like Twitter (X), Reddit, and MMA communities picked up on Rogan’s comments. Many agreed, citing the fact that Francis Ngannou—arguably the most dangerous heavyweight in recent history—is no longer in the UFC. Others pointed to Ciryl Gane’s high-profile losses to Ngannou and Jones as evidence that the division is thin at the very top.

Meanwhile, critics questioned whether fighters like Sergei Pavlovich, Jailton Almeida, or Alexander Volkov truly inspire the same excitement as past heavyweight legends.

Tom Aspinall’s Response: A Champion’s Perspective

Confidence in the Division’s Depth

Tom Aspinall did not mince words in responding to the “shallow” label. While acknowledging that the division might lack “name value” compared to its golden years, Aspinall argued that the technical level of today’s heavyweights is higher than ever. Fighters are faster, more well-rounded, and better prepared than previous generations.

Aspinall stated: “The level of the guys is really good, actually. People might not realize it because some of the names are newer, but the division is going to flourish in the next few years.”

Looking Toward the Future

Rather than dwelling on the absence of Ngannou or the uncertainty of Jon Jones’s future, Aspinall emphasized the arrival of new signings and up-and-coming talent. He firmly believes that this new wave of heavyweights will inject excitement back into the division and keep fans invested.

For Aspinall, defending the division isn’t just about silencing critics—it’s about reshaping the narrative. As the champion, he sees himself as both a representative and protector of the division, tasked with showing fans and analysts that heavyweight MMA still delivers must-watch moments.

Evaluating the Current State of the Heavyweight Division

Tom Aspinall: The Future Face of Heavyweight MMA

Tom Aspinall’s meteoric rise is the centerpiece of the division’s revival. At just 31 years old, the English powerhouse has already established himself as one of the most complete heavyweights in UFC history. His blend of speed, knockout power, and Brazilian jiu-jitsu black belt credentials make him a nightmare matchup for any opponent.

Aspinall’s performances have been nothing short of spectacular, with multiple first-round finishes and dominant wins over top contenders. His charisma and confidence outside the Octagon only enhance his role as the potential face of the heavyweight division for years to come.

Ciryl Gane: The Technician

Ciryl “Bon Gamin” Gane, despite criticisms, remains one of the most technically gifted heavyweights the UFC has ever seen. His Muay Thai background and fluid movement often resemble a middleweight rather than a 250-pound fighter.

While Gane has faced criticism for his grappling deficiencies—exposed in losses to Ngannou and Jones—his striking mastery ensures he will remain a perennial contender. His upcoming fight with Aspinall at UFC 321 represents a chance for redemption and an opportunity to reclaim his reputation.

Sergei Pavlovich: The Knockout Machine

Russian contender Sergei Pavlovich has become one of the most feared heavyweights on the planet. With devastating knockout power in both hands, Pavlovich has made quick work of several top opponents. His ability to end fights in seconds makes him a must-watch fighter and a dangerous challenger for the title.

Jailton Almeida: The Grappling Specialist

Brazil’s Jailton Almeida brings a different flavor to the heavyweight division. His elite grappling skills, relentless takedowns, and submission arsenal have drawn comparisons to legends like Fabricio Werdum. Almeida’s rise represents the growing diversity of fighting styles within the division.

Alexander Volkov and Veteran Presence

Veterans like Alexander Volkov continue to provide stability in the rankings. With his towering frame and extensive experience, Volkov serves as a litmus test for up-and-coming fighters while remaining a legitimate threat himself.

Why the “Shallow” Label May Be Misleading

1. Skill Evolution
   Today’s heavyweights are not just brawlers; they are complete mixed martial artists. Fighters like Aspinall and Gane bring technical precision and cardio previously rare in the division.

2. Global Expansion
   The UFC is signing talent from across the world, including Russia, Brazil, and Europe. This international influx ensures fresh matchups and compelling storylines.

3. Comparisons with the Past
   Critics often compare today’s division to the golden age of Cain Velasquez, Junior dos Santos, and Stipe Miocic. But skill-for-skill, many current fighters could arguably compete with those legends.

4. Narrative Control
   Public perception often hinges on a handful of marquee names. With Ngannou gone and Jones potentially near retirement, the division may feel thin—but new stars are already rising.

The Role of UFC 321: Aspinall vs Gane

Why This Fight Matters

The headline fight at UFC 321, featuring Tom Aspinall vs Ciryl Gane, is more than just a title defense. It is a referendum on the state of the heavyweight division.

• If Aspinall wins convincingly, he solidifies himself as the face of the future and silences doubters.

• If Gane redeems himself with an improved performance, he proves that the division still has compelling, world-class talent.

Fan and Analyst Expectations

Fans are divided, with UK supporters rallying behind Aspinall and French fans eager to see Gane reclaim his place at the top. Analysts see the fight as a clash of contrasting styles—Aspinall’s speed and explosiveness versus Gane’s patience and technical striking.

This fight could mark the start of a new heavyweight era, one defined not by the shadow of past legends but by the rise of new ones.

The Business Side: Why Heavyweight Still Matters

The UFC has always leaned on heavyweight fights to sell pay-per-views. Historically, heavyweight bouts have drawn mainstream attention because of their unpredictability and potential for highlight-reel knockouts.

For Aspinall and the UFC, keeping the division relevant is crucial for global marketing, particularly in Europe, where Aspinall’s success could ignite a new wave of UK-based MMA fans, much like Conor McGregor did for Ireland at featherweight and lightweight.

Looking Ahead: The Future of the Heavyweight Division

1. The Jones Question
   Will Jon Jones return to defend his belt against Aspinall? If he does, it will be one of the biggest fights in UFC history. If not, Aspinall has the opportunity to carry the torch himself.

2. Emerging Contenders
   Fighters like Pavlovich and Almeida are already knocking on the door. Their rise ensures that the division will not lack storylines.

3. New Signings and Global Talent
   As Aspinall mentioned, the UFC is signing new heavyweights, and the next breakout star could already be training in a gym somewhere in Europe, Africa, or South America.

Conclusion

The narrative that the UFC heavyweight division is “shallow” may be premature. While the absence of names like Francis Ngannou and the uncertainty around Jon Jones have created a perception problem, the division is far from devoid of talent.

Tom Aspinall has not only defended his belt but also defended the pride of the heavyweight class. His belief in the division’s future, combined with the rise of fighters like Ciryl Gane, Sergei Pavlovich, and Jailton Almeida, signals that the next few years could usher in a new golden era.

At UFC 321, all eyes will be on Aspinall and Gane. The outcome will not just determine a champion—it will determine the direction of an entire division. Whether fans and analysts continue to call it “shallow” or begin to view it as resurgent may well depend on what happens inside the Octagon that night.

One thing is certain: heavyweight MMA still matters, and Tom Aspinall is determined to make sure everyone knows it.