Becky & Seth Hold All the Power – But If Punk Plays This Secret Ace, the Entire WWE Hierarchy Could Collapse!

The return of CM Punk to WWE has been one of the most explosive storylines in recent memory. Fans knew there would be fireworks, but few could have predicted just how personal things would get. At the center of it all stands Seth Rollins, a man who has never hidden his hatred for Punk, and who has gone to extraordinary lengths to keep the “Second City Saint” away from championship gold. Their latest chapter at Clash in Paris ended in bitter controversy when Rollins, with help from his wife Becky Lynch, once again prevented Punk from walking away as champion. The betrayal stung deeper than ever because it wasn’t just Seth Rollins pulling the strings—it was Becky Lynch herself stepping into the line of fire for her husband.

The sight of WWE’s most powerful couple working together against Punk has left fans buzzing with one burning question: Who can Punk trust to fight by his side? Wrestling has always been about shocking alliances, surprise returns, and grudges that never die. This feud has every ingredient to produce WWE’s next blockbuster rivalry. Below, we break down the most intriguing superstars—past and present—who could step into Punk’s corner and flip the balance of power.

AJ Lee – The Return Fans Have Dreamed Of

Let’s address the elephant in the room right away. Ever since Punk walked back through WWE’s doors, the whispers have been deafening: Will AJ Lee return? She’s not just Punk’s real-life partner but also one of the most influential women in WWE history. Long before the Women’s Evolution became a buzzword, AJ Lee was raising the bar and proving that women could steal the show. Her impact on the division is undeniable, and her absence has left a void that fans desperately want filled. Bringing AJ back at this exact moment would be a storytelling masterstroke. Not only would she instantly reignite the women’s division, but her personal connection to Punk makes the potential feud with Becky Lynch all the more compelling.

Imagine the promos. Imagine the face-to-face moments between AJ and Becky. Imagine the ticket sales. If WWE is looking for a return that checks every possible box—nostalgia, storytelling, and star power—AJ Lee is the one.

Bayley – A Grudge That Aligns Perfectly

If AJ Lee is the fantasy pick, Bayley might be the most logical one. Her history with Becky Lynch has been boiling over for months. Fans haven’t forgotten the moment Lynch took Bayley’s WrestleMania spot, sparking a bitter rivalry that has seen Bayley chasing revenge at every turn.

Aligning with Punk would not only give Bayley the perfect platform to finally exact her revenge but also elevate this feud into a war of factions. Bayley’s current character shift, with hints of her darker “heel” persona creeping back in, adds even more weight to the possibility. Imagine Bayley standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Punk, both united by a common enemy in Seth and Becky. For Bayley, this would be personal. For Punk, this would be strategic. And for fans, this would be can’t-miss television.

Nikki Bella – The Wild Card Choice

On the surface, a Nikki Bella and CM Punk alliance sounds unexpected, maybe even random. But in WWE, the most unlikely partnerships often create the loudest buzz. Nikki has her own unfinished business with Becky Lynch after their controversial matchups, and pairing her with Punk would give fans a fresh dynamic.

The Bella brand still carries weight, and Nikki’s presence would generate mainstream attention far beyond the usual WWE audience. While this might not be the most natural fit compared to AJ or Bayley, it’s the kind of shock factor move WWE has never been afraid to pull. It wouldn’t be about long-term storytelling but about creating a feud so unpredictable that fans can’t look away. Sometimes, that’s all it takes to capture the cultural conversation.

Cora Jade – Blurring Reality and Fiction

Here’s where things get spicy. Few names could send the internet into meltdown like Cora Jade stepping back into WWE programming alongside CM Punk. Why? Because Jade’s real-life friction with Becky Lynch has been a point of discussion among fans ever since their social media spat earlier this year.

Many even speculated that the tension played a role in Jade’s absence from WWE television. Bringing her back now, right as Becky cements herself as the villain of this storyline, would blur the lines between kayfabe and reality in a way that only WWE can pull off. Jade’s rebellious, anti-establishment persona aligns perfectly with Punk’s own reputation as a disruptor. Together, they could embody a new wave of defiance aimed directly at the so-called power couple of WWE. And let’s be honest—the promos between Jade and Becky would be absolute fire.

Lyra Valkyria – Unfinished Business With “The Man”

Sometimes, the best stories are the ones already written. Lyra Valkyria and Becky Lynch tore the house down this past summer in one of WWE’s most underrated feuds. While Becky ultimately stood tall, the rivalry gave Lyra the chance to show the world she’s a future star. But anyone who watched closely knows that feud didn’t end clean.

Bayley’s involvement played a huge role, leaving Valkyria with plenty of reasons to still hold a grudge. Her absence from TV since then has only fueled speculation about what WWE has planned for her. Imagine the shock if she returned in dramatic fashion—this time at Punk’s side. The story practically writes itself: Lyra has unfinished business, Punk needs backup, and Becky Lynch won’t know what hit her. Pairing a rising star with a veteran like Punk would also create the kind of “passing the torch” moment WWE thrives on.

Why This Story Matters More Than Just a Feud

What makes this angle so fascinating is that it isn’t just about wins and losses. It’s about trust, betrayal, and power. Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch aren’t just another WWE couple—they are arguably the most dominant duo in the company’s history, holding multiple championships and commanding massive fan loyalty. For Punk to survive, let alone triumph, he needs someone who can stand toe-to-toe with Lynch while he battles Rollins. This is bigger than CM Punk’s quest for gold. 

This is about shifting the balance of power in WWE. Whoever steps into Punk’s corner will instantly be thrust into one of the most high-profile storylines of the year, if not the decade. And in WWE, those moments don’t just create matches—they create legends.

Final Word – Who Will Punk Choose?

At the end of the day, speculation is part of the fun. Fans will debate endlessly whether it will be AJ Lee’s long-awaited return, Bayley’s perfect revenge arc, Nikki Bella’s headline-grabbing shock factor, Cora Jade’s reality-blurring comeback, or Lyra Valkyria’s unfinished business that tips the scales. What we do know is this: CM Punk cannot fight this war alone.

Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch have proven they are willing to play every card in the deck to keep their stranglehold on WWE. The next chapter of this feud could define careers, shift divisions, and cement legacies. The only question is—who’s willing to take that risk and stand beside the Second City Saint? One thing is certain: WWE fans will be watching, waiting, and speculating until the next big twist drops. And when it does, the wrestling world will never be the same again.