Is Amsterdam Just Another Overhyped Margot Robbie Vehicle? Critics Say Yes!

Netflix has recently added the 2022 period drama Amsterdam to its growing library of acclaimed films, offering viewers a unique blend of historical fiction, political intrigue, and star-powered performances. Featuring Margot Robbie, Christian Bale, and John David Washington in lead roles, the film immerses audiences in a turbulent 1930s America filled with conspiracy, friendship, and dark secrets.

Directed by Oscar-winning filmmaker David O. Russell, known for hits like Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle, Amsterdam stands out as a bold attempt to fuse history and fiction through a stylish, character-driven narrative. Despite receiving mixed reviews from critics upon release, the film has found a warmer reception among many viewers, especially since its arrival on Netflix.

In this detailed review, we explore what makes Amsterdam an intriguing watch in 2025 — from its compelling cast and meticulous production design to its daring storytelling and historical backdrop.

A Star-Studded Cast Anchors Amsterdam

One of the primary draws of Amsterdam is its impressive ensemble cast, headlined by Christian Bale, Margot Robbie, and John David Washington.

Christian Bale plays Burt Berendsen, a quirky and troubled doctor whose complex character anchors much of the film’s emotional weight. Bale’s reputation for deep immersion into his roles is well-known, and here, he delivers a performance that balances charm, vulnerability, and intensity.

Opposite him is Margot Robbie as Valerie Voze, a fiercely ambitious nurse and artist whose enigmatic personality drives much of the narrative’s energy. Robbie’s portrayal brings intelligence and subtlety, highlighting her versatility as an actress capable of commanding both dramatic and lighter scenes.

John David Washington rounds out the trio as Harold Woodman, a war veteran turned lawyer. Washington’s performance offers a grounded counterbalance, giving the film heart and a sense of earnestness. The chemistry among these three leads—representing a deep friendship forged in hardship—is a cornerstone of the movie’s appeal.

Supporting the leads is a remarkable cast featuring Zoe Saldana, Rami Malek, Anya Taylor-Joy, and screen legend Robert De Niro. Their performances enrich the story’s complexity and bring additional gravitas to the unfolding political drama.

Additionally, cameos by Mike Myers, Chris Rock, and pop star Taylor Swift add surprising moments of humor and cultural texture, keeping the film lively and unpredictable.

Plot Summary: Intrigue and Conspiracy in 1930s New York

Set in 1933, the film follows the lives of three lifelong friends who become prime suspects in a shocking murder case. As they strive to prove their innocence, they stumble upon a sinister conspiracy involving wealthy elites and an attempt to overthrow President Franklin D. Roosevelt.

This storyline draws loosely from the real-life but little-known Business Plot, an alleged political conspiracy in the early 1930s aimed at staging a coup against Roosevelt’s administration. Amsterdam takes this historical event and weaves it into a fictional thriller that explores themes of loyalty, justice, and resistance against corruption.

Under the direction of David O. Russell, the narrative balances suspense with moments of dark humor and emotional resonance, creating a tone that is both playful and thought-provoking. This blend of genres—mystery, political thriller, and period drama—makes Amsterdam stand out in Netflix’s collection of historical films.

Visuals and Production Design: A Meticulous Recreation of the Era

One of the film’s strongest assets is its production design, which painstakingly recreates the atmosphere of 1930s America. From opulent parties and smoky jazz clubs to medical offices and courtroom settings, every detail reflects the period’s aesthetics and social tensions.

Costumes play a crucial role in immersing the audience in the era. Designed by the talented J.R. Hawbaker, the wardrobe features authentic fabrics, bold silhouettes, and exquisite accessories that reflect each character’s personality and status. Whether it’s Valerie’s eccentric nurse outfits or Burt’s worn-in doctor’s coat, the costumes tell stories of their own.

Complementing the visual storytelling is the cinematography, which captures both the gritty realities and glamor of the time, using lighting and camera techniques that evoke nostalgia and tension simultaneously.

Audience Reception vs. Critical Response

While Amsterdam struggled with critics, earning a modest 31% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, the audience response has been notably more positive, with about 65% of viewers on Google Reviews expressing enjoyment and appreciation.

Many viewers praise the film for its strong performances, especially from Margot Robbie and Christian Bale, as well as its rich visual style and complex character dynamics. The soundtrack and sound design are also frequently mentioned for enhancing the immersive experience.

For example, one viewer commented:
“The music throughout was fantastic, and Christian Bale leads an incredibly talented cast. The period details in the sets and costumes were superb, making the world feel alive and authentic. Even when the story took liberties with historical accuracy, it didn’t detract from the overall experience—it actually enhanced the atmosphere.”

Another praised Margot Robbie’s performance, saying:
“Margot Robbie continues to impress with her nuanced, intelligent portrayals. She brings depth and humanity to Valerie Voze, making her one of the most memorable characters I’ve seen in recent films.”

However, not all reactions were glowing. Some critics found the film’s tone uneven and the plot overly convoluted. Yet, the general audience appreciation suggests that Amsterdam resonates with viewers willing to engage with its layered storytelling and offbeat style.

Why Amsterdam Is a Worthy Addition to Netflix’s Collection

Amsterdam offers a compelling viewing experience for those interested in historical dramas, political thrillers, and character-driven narratives. Its availability on Netflix provides an accessible way for audiences worldwide to explore this unique film.

The streaming platform also allows viewers to watch at their own pace, which is beneficial given the film’s intricate plot and rich cast of characters. Pausing and revisiting scenes can deepen understanding and appreciation of the story’s nuances.

Moreover, the film’s exploration of friendship, political corruption, and resistance against authoritarianism carries themes that remain relevant today, inviting reflection beyond its period setting.

Final Thoughts: A Bold, Ambitious Film Elevated by Margot Robbie and Christian Bale

Though Amsterdam may not have achieved blockbuster status, its arrival on Netflix offers a fresh opportunity to experience a film that dares to blend genres and take creative risks.

At its core, Amsterdam is a story about friendship, loyalty, and standing up to power. The performances of Margot Robbie, Christian Bale, and John David Washington elevate the film, bringing heart and complexity to a narrative filled with suspense and intrigue.

If you are looking for a period drama with political edge, stellar acting, and lush production values, Amsterdam on Netflix is a film worth watching.