UFC Champion Islam Makhachev Makes a Bold Decision in the Fight Against Ilia Topuria – Could Another Fight Completely Change His Legacy?

In the ever-evolving world of mixed martial arts, bold decisions often define champions. For UFC Lightweight Champion Islam Makhachev, that moment might be unfolding now. With a dominant reign at 155 pounds, whispers of a superfight against newly crowned UFC Featherweight Champion Ilia Topuria are heating up—and Makhachev’s latest statements suggest he’s open to a move that could dramatically reshape the future of his career and legacy. But what does this bold move mean for the UFC, the fans, and the long-term perception of Makhachev as one of the greatest fighters in the sport? Could another fight—perhaps outside of his current weight class—end up defining his legacy more than any lightweight title defense? Let’s dive deep into this potential clash, the implications surrounding it, and how Islam Makhachev’s willingness to take risks might cement, or even redefine, his status in UFC history.

The Rise of Islam Makhachev: Dominance in the Lightweight Division

Islam Makhachev has carved a dominant path in the UFC’s stacked lightweight division. Following in the footsteps of his close friend and mentor Khabib Nurmagomedov, Makhachev has combined suffocating grappling, calculated striking, and an iron will to become one of the most complete fighters in the sport. Since capturing the lightweight belt in October 2022 with a masterful win over Charles Oliveira at UFC 280, Makhachev has successfully defended his title against top contenders like Alexander Volkanovski and Justin Gaethje. His performance against Volkanovski—especially in their rematch at UFC 294—cemented his place atop the pound-for-pound rankings and reinforced his status as a cerebral fighter capable of adjusting to any opponent. But even for a champion as dominant as Makhachev, staying at the top of one division can only build your legacy so far. As the featherweight division evolves, new challenges emerge, and among them, none are more tantalizing than Ilia Topuria.

Ilia Topuria: The Dangerous New King at Featherweight

Ilia Topuria’s meteoric rise through the featherweight division culminated in a spectacular knockout victory over Alexander Volkanovski at UFC 298. With this victory, Topuria not only claimed the 145-pound belt but also sent shockwaves through the MMA world by dethroning one of the most respected champions in UFC history. Topuria brings an aggressive, well-rounded skillset with crisp boxing, powerful kicks, and a high fight IQ. Unbeaten in his MMA career, he has quickly become one of the UFC’s brightest stars, with many pundits touting him as the next big pay-per-view draw. Now, with Topuria reigning at featherweight and Makhachev ruling lightweight, the stage is being set for a potential superfight between two champions in their prime. It’s the kind of matchup that could transcend divisions and generate enormous global interest.

A Bold Decision: Makhachev Eyes Topuria Showdown

In recent interviews, Islam Makhachev has hinted that he’s not only interested in facing Ilia Topuria—but that he may even be willing to drop down to 145 pounds to challenge for the featherweight belt. This would be a shocking move for several reasons. Makhachev has always been known for his size and strength at lightweight, and the idea of him cutting additional weight to fight a fast, power-packed featherweight like Topuria raises obvious concerns. But it also signals Makhachev’s hunger for greatness. Makhachev vs Topuria isn’t just another fight—it’s a potential legacy-defining moment. If Makhachev can successfully cut to featherweight and dethrone Topuria, he would become a rare two-division UFC champion, joining the elite company of legends like Conor McGregor, Daniel Cormier, Amanda Nunes, and Henry Cejudo. And even if the fight takes place at a catchweight or involves Topuria moving up to lightweight, it still represents a high-risk, high-reward clash that could have massive implications.

Islam Makhachev legacy in MMA

What makes this decision so bold is what’s truly at stake: not just a title, but Makhachev’s legacy in MMA. Dominating one weight class is an accomplishment few achieve. But conquering multiple divisions, especially against an undefeated rising star like Topuria, takes a fighter from “great” to “legendary.” There’s always a gamble in these kinds of moves. Weight cuts can sap energy and performance. Fighters lose their edge when they step out of their comfort zone. Just ask T.J. Dillashaw, whose move to flyweight to challenge Henry Cejudo ended in disaster. But for Islam Makhachev, the allure of legacy might outweigh the risks. In a sport that constantly evolves and rewards boldness, standing still can be just as dangerous as moving forward. Makhachev’s team—headed by coach Javier Mendez—has a history of calculated risks, and they understand the value of historical greatness. A win over Topuria could instantly elevate Makhachev into the all-time great conversation, alongside fighters like Georges St-Pierre, Anderson Silva, and Jon Jones.

UFC superfight potential: Makhachev vs McGregor or Edwards?

As thrilling as a showdown with Topuria would be, some argue that there might be another fight with even greater implications for Makhachev’s legacy. One name continues to loom large over the division—and the entire UFC: Conor McGregor. While McGregor hasn’t fought at lightweight since his loss to Dustin Poirier in 2021, the Irish superstar still commands unparalleled global attention. A hypothetical Makhachev vs McGregor fight would break records, sell millions of pay-per-views, and draw interest from casual and hardcore fans alike. For Makhachev, defeating McGregor would be both personal and professional. The Dagestani camp has long been intertwined with the McGregor rivalry, dating back to Khabib’s infamous win at UFC 229. By beating McGregor, Makhachev could not only avenge his mentor but also step out of Khabib’s shadow once and for all. Another tantalizing option is a clash with Leon Edwards, the reigning welterweight champion. If Makhachev moves up to 170 and defeats Edwards, he would achieve something even Khabib never attempted: conquering a second division in a heavier weight class. Such a feat would skyrocket his pound-for-pound ranking and solidify his place in history.

UFC two-division champions and pound-for-pound greatness

Becoming a two-division champion isn’t just about belts—it’s about respect. It’s about proving your skillset translates across weight classes, and that your fight IQ, technique, and willpower are elite at any level. If Makhachev beats Topuria and captures the featherweight belt, his name would be written into the history books alongside the UFC’s most iconic figures. Pound-for-pound greatness isn’t just determined by title defenses. It’s defined by moments—iconic fights, daring challenges, and victories that resonate beyond the sport. Islam Makhachev’s next opponent, whether it’s Topuria, McGregor, or Edwards, could offer one of those moments. A dominant win would make it harder than ever to deny him the title of best fighter in the world.

What the Fans Are Saying

The MMA community is buzzing with speculation. On social media, fans are split. Some believe Topuria’s speed and power could be too much for a drained Makhachev. Others see the Dagestani’s elite grappling and experience as the perfect foil for the younger champion. Either way, the anticipation is palpable—and that’s exactly what the UFC thrives on. Analysts also point out that Makhachev has improved dramatically in striking, evidenced by his head-kick knockout of Volkanovski in their rematch. If he brings that same composure and accuracy against Topuria, the fight could go either way.

Conclusion: Will Makhachev Take the Leap?

Islam Makhachev stands at a crossroads. Continue ruling over the lightweight division with safe, dominant wins—or take a risk, chase greatness, and etch his name into the history books with a bold move that few would dare attempt. A fight with Ilia Topuria would be one of the most anticipated matchups in UFC history. But it could also come at a steep price. Should he win, Makhachev could rise to unprecedented heights. Should he lose, questions about his move—and his future—will follow. But in the fight game, fortune favors the bold. And Makhachev seems ready to chase greatness, no matter the cost. Whether he steps into the Octagon against Topuria, McGregor, or a welterweight titan like Leon Edwards, one thing is certain: Islam Makhachev’s next fight could completely change his legacy.